News location:

Canberra Today 12°/16° | Saturday, April 20, 2024 | Digital Edition | Crossword & Sudoku

Lancaster breaks concert to slam ANU

Dr Geoffrey Lancaster
In a passionate speech delivered unexpectedly at a Canberra International Music Festival concert today, one of Australia’s most prominent pianists accused the ANU of betraying staff at the School of Music.

Breaking from the advertised program of Mozart sonatas, Geoffrey Lancaster said: “Evil is rampant at the ANU… the ANU have lied to us, they have betrayed us,” adding that this it had gone unchecked and uncriticised.

And he named names, urging those present to “hold up”  the names of ANU vice-chancellor Ian Young, Marnie “whatshername” [deputy vice-chancellor (academic) Prof Marnie Hughes-Warrington], dean of the College of Arts & Social Sciences  Toni Makkai; head of the School of Music Adrian Walter and church music expert Jonathan Powles, whom he described as  “very much the architect of this [the proposed  new music program] course”.

He also urged people to adopt a magnanimous attitude. “Let us hope they find a point of repentance,” he said.

Dr Lancaster’s very public remarks were greeted with a standing ovation from an audience of Mozart-lovers gathered to hear him join fellow School of Music staffer, Alan Hicks, at the fortepiano in the Turkish Embassy’s Lalezar Hall.

A professor at the Royal College of Music in London and recipient of a Keating Fellowship  before joining the School of Music, Dr Lancaster said he was a straightforward person who wanted to say it as he saw it.

After his speech, he sat down to perform a “surprise” work, a “lament for the School of Music”.

His  program notes were already feisty enough, Dr Lancaster charging that Western music was dominated by the idea that to be deep, it had to be tragic, whereas Mozart was loved just because of his pleasing melodies and his fondness for major keys.

Events on the Canberra music scene seemed to demand a minor key.

Who can be trusted?

In a world of spin and confusion, there’s never been a more important time to support independent journalism in Canberra.

If you trust our work online and want to enforce the power of independent voices, I invite you to make a small contribution.

Every dollar of support is invested back into our journalism to help keep citynews.com.au strong and free.

Become a supporter

Thank you,

Ian Meikle, editor

Helen Musa

Helen Musa

Share this

12 Responses to Lancaster breaks concert to slam ANU

Pamela McKay says: 13 May 2012 at 5:46 pm

Hooray fo Geofrey ! The saga of the breakup of the School of Music began in 2004, when I was the Venue Manager there & the new ‘hand’ in the School of Arts began slicing through the staff – Head of School, Deputy Head, my position – all sliced., with little thought as to what the outcomes would be for those people & the students..And so it continues. What a disgraceful way of treating staff & students.

Reply
William Martin says: 14 May 2012 at 7:28 am

Now we know why Walter wanted leave. He knew announcement of his appointment to Hong Kong APA was taking place and needed to get away from predictable furious backlash. Slash staff and program, promptly parachute out of country. Or it could read “flees Australia”.

Reply
Janet Thomas says: 14 May 2012 at 10:44 am

It is an appalling situation whichever way you look at it. Good on you Geoffrey for your honesty and for having the courage to speak out! From my limited perspective, all I can see is a great Music School being gutted. It is staffed by high profile and enthusiastic performers and teachers who are generous with their time and devotion to teaching and performance programs. The hardworking and dedicated support staff have also been very shabbily treated in this shake up. One wonders if it is worth their while to bring their lunches or will they be shown the door before the day is out? In the meantime, it will be a great loss to the Canberra community – not only for the wonderful performances by SoM staff and students, but also the opportunities provided through the Infants, Junior and Secondary Schools programs in fostering local students – some of whom subsequently pursue tertiary studies and a career in music. Geoffrey Lancaster himself is a Canberra original who went on to achieve international success and it was wonderful to see him return to Canberra to share his knowledge, and for the community to enjoy his sterling performances. Are the authors of these moves being a little shortsighted and relegating Canberra to a musical backwater? Not everyone can afford to travel to Sydney or Melbourne for concerts and musical education opportunities.

Reply
Pete says: 14 May 2012 at 4:48 pm

Sad to see the passionate people being misinform about the restructure of the SoM. Not to mention that what has been announced is for public consultation not the final plan.
Of cause people can disagree and raise their concern that is part of consultation process but to mention any individual name, without them being able to defence their name, as if anyone of these people doing this for fun is beyond and form of sensible campaign. Shame on CIMF organiser to let someone like Geoffrey Lancaster to ruin what is a wonderful festival. I was disturbed by his comment and will not attend anymore of the concern that Geoffrey is feature in. I don’t mind loud music but loud mouth is just intolerable.

Reply
Janet Thomas says: 17 May 2012 at 10:18 am

Sorry Pete but I must say you sound sadly misinformed and lacking experience in University processes. Having worked in the tertiary sector at a very high profile and well respected Australian University for over 25 years and more recently at the ANU School of Music, I have seen my share of underhanded tactics but this beats everything! Those individuals who were named were well aware of what they were doing. I’m not sure if Adrian Walter was the “patsy” in all this. Naming names? If you are prepared to act as some have, then you must take the consequences. The staff had no means of defence either. Despite your belief that there was a consultation process, the staff were presented with a fait accompli. There was no consultation process at all. The main players in this saga kept the whole thing under wraps until it was announced to SoM staff that all their positions would be abolished and curriculum dismantled. Of course you are entitled to your opinion over Geoffrey’s announcement mid recital but there is a lot at stake here and Geoffrey has always called it as he sees it. His honesty in doing so is in direct contrast to those who worked in the shadows. There is an all pervading sense of sadness in SoM as so much is to be destroyed. There is also a lot of bad feeling and resentment towards traitors in the ranks.

Reply
Dr Robert Davidson says: 17 May 2012 at 10:34 am

“Traitors in the ranks” is surely a bit strong as a way to describe people who have a different opinion on the best way to proceed.

Reply
Janet Thomas says: 17 May 2012 at 11:32 am

Could be seen as strong language to describe what has happened but in view of the way proceedings were conducted, I would stand by my description. I might add the expressions “snakes”, “treachery ” have oft been repeated since the announcement. The standout is the absence of consultation with all senior music staff. It is my understanding that there was no executive meeting with all heads of areas to discuss potential changes in curriculum – as would happen in normal collegial process within a teaching department. Thus it is not a matter of different opinion but rather the attempted foisting of opinion through flawed process. Robust, open discussion with all essential players should have been the order of the day.

Reply
Pete (patsy as Janet suggested) says: 17 May 2012 at 11:00 am

Damage, Janet, you caught me out! I am Patsy. I would not said that I am misinformed by any measures.

Reply
Michael B says: 16 May 2012 at 10:33 pm

Well done Chris Latham and the Festival for allowing people who are brave enough to speak up against brutality, and thank you so very much Geoffrey Lancaster for sharing your honest opinion about the disgraceful way ANU behaved towards you and colleagues. Geoffrey is a distinguished SoM alumnus and one of Canberra’s most prominent, respected and loyal citizens. This was among the best concerts of the Festival because of Geoffrey’s sincere remarks and his virtuosic performances with Alan. This whole affair at the ANU is a ham-fisted mess because of a decision to put profit over the arts but then failing to consult with the most experienced music staff before dumping the existing very successful music program.

Reply
Karen Dahl says: 17 May 2012 at 11:07 pm

Dear Geoffrey You get my heartfelt thanks. What a speech. And what an action this evening to not turn up for your next concert at the Turkish Embassy. It was absolutely the right thing to do although we all sorely missed your playing….We need to up the fight to save the ANU School of Music. Frankly, it’s now whatever action it takes to reverse the ill-conceived and counter-productive situation…Thanks for showing you’ve got a good strong sense of justice…

Reply
John Warnr says: 18 May 2012 at 8:27 pm

Dear Dr Lancaster,
WELL DONE! people on your scale have more welly than people on mine.
Management has done its usual thing. Men that have no music in their souls, fit for only stratagems and spoils etc.. should not be running schools of music.

Solidarity. John Warner

Reply

Leave a Reply

Related Posts

Theatre

Holiday musical off to Madagascar

Director Nina Stevenson is at it again, with her company Pied Piper's school holiday production of Madagascar JR - A Musical Adventure, a family show with all the characters from the movie.

Follow us on Instagram @canberracitynews