CIMF Review / Struggle to pair children’s songs with indigenous music

Music / CIMF Concert 6: “Dreaming Across the Horizon (Memories of Childhood),” Fitters’ Workshop, April 30. Reviewed by JUDITH CRISPIN

Didgeridoo player William Barton…”the combination of traditional folk scoring (including guitar and tambourine) and references to indigenous music was jarring and, at times, coarse.” Photo by Peter Hislop

SITTING in the Fitters’ Workshop, Sunday night, waiting for “Dreaming Across the Horizon” to begin, I wondered how such a concert program was going to work.

Andrew Ford’s arrangements of Anglo-Celtic children’s songs were to be paired with indigenous Australian music. It would be a difficult task to present something cohesive while, at the same time, navigating the political minefield of cultural appropriation – and, frankly, I don’t think this concert achieved it.

There were undoubtedly some lovely moments in Ford’s song cycle. More Britten than Berio, Ford adopted a conservative, minimal language – something the late century Modernists might have called “wrong note tonality” – but it suited the mood. Highlights included “Aiken Drum”, where Ford used tonal layers and a growing dissonance to great dramatic effect. 

“Little Star”, a Ford setting of words by Ann and Jane Taylor, was beautifully sung by Tobias Cole accompanied by elegant harp lines (Meriel Owen).

Coles’s tone, line and sense of legato were, as always, flawless and Ford’s handling of harmony in this song is stunning. But there were awkward moments, too. An over-dramatised, pseudo-Celtic cabaret marred a subsequent song. Ford is a fine craftsman and his subtle handling of tone colour and dynamic is testimony to that. But somehow the songs were a little too conservative, a little too simplistic and, occasionally, a little clichéd. 

William Barton presented a virtuosic didgeridoo improvisation. Barton’s breath control, his dramaturgy and command of tone are truly admirable. The connection between the Song cycle and the improvisation, however, was not at all apparent and one wondered why the decision to proceed from one to the other without pause was made.

Featuring the very professional and endearing children’s choirs of Turner Trebles and Vocal Fry, Chris Sainsbury’s “Juljul” (Jumping Ant) was more homage than appropriation – and yet, the spectacle of white musicians presenting indigenous music to a white audience was not altogether comfortable.

Brenda Gifford’s “Galaa” was far more successful. Written mostly in Dhurga language, Gifford skilfully combined folk idiom with traditional indigenous elements. The musical direction of Roland Peelman should be commended – though he was one of a number of musicians to be left off the printed program. “Dreaming Across the Horizon” featured some fine musicians –William Barton and Tobias Cole stood out for me – and some interesting works. But no single piece was strong enough to carry the program.


, , , ,

One Response to “CIMF Review / Struggle to pair children’s songs with indigenous music”

  1. Ali Murphy-Oates
    May 17, 2017 at 3:10 pm #

    Christopher Sainsbury is a proud Dharug man and a teacher and mentor to many First Peoples composers. May I suggest the reviewer check their own assumptions about what the first peoples of this land must look and sound like, acquaint themselves with the last 229 years of invasion, genocide, removal of our children and assimilation policies and how that has impacted on fair skinned First Nations people, and READ THE PROGRAM before attempting to review our art again.

Leave a Reply

Leave your opinion here. Please be nice. Your Email address will be kept private.
%d bloggers like this: