It turned into a profitable day for the Nats

Share Canberra's trusted news:

With the minor party deeply split and its rebels out of control, and hard line Nationals and moderate Liberals exchanging shots over coal, the government is distracted and risks being destabilised, writes political columnist MICHELLE GRATTAN. 

THE Nationals’ internal turmoil has created further chaos in the Coalition, with rebel backbencher Llew O’Brien defying the government to win a House of Representatives vote for deputy speaker – a day after quitting his party.

Michelle Grattan

In a highly astute tactical play, Labor nominated O’Brien, who defeated the government candidate, Nationals’ whip Damian Drum, 75-67.

Labor had 64 votes, with the other 11 votes in the secret ballot coming from a combination of crossbenchers – of whom there are six – and dissident Nationals. If all the crossbenchers voted for O’Brien, that meant he got five Nationals votes.

In the chamber, Scott Morrison and Nationals leader Michael McCormack were forced to swallow their fury at the government’s public humiliation and congratulate O’Brien.

“With two government members to choose from I’m pleased to see government members received the full confidence of all the members of the House”, Morrison said. McCormack said: “That’s democracy”.

McCormack, who held his position last week in face of Barnaby Joyce’s challenge, has been further weakened by the latest shenanigans.

With the minor party deeply split and its rebels out of control, and hard line Nationals and moderate Liberals exchanging shots over coal, the government is distracted and risks being destabilised.

O’Brien’s extraordinary 24 hours began with his indicating he was resigning from the Nationals, during a Sunday row with McCormack.


But he remains a member of the Queensland Liberal National Party. Under this arrangement he won’t attend the Nationals party room but will go to the Coalition party meetings.

A former policeman who holds the Queensland seat of Wide Bay, O’Brien said he did not know Labor would nominate him for the post of deputy speaker, which became vacant with the appointment of Kevin Hogan to the frontbench. (Hogan, incidentally, moved to the crossbench during the last parliament, sitting as an “independent National” while remaining in the National party. He moved back to the government benches after the election.)

O’Brien’s elevation brings him a pay rise of some $42,000, additional travel entitlement and an extra staffer.

After winning the ballot, O’Brien said he would be meeting the PM on Monday night and “firming up” his arrangements to stay within the government.

Asked whether he’d be crossing the floor on legislation, he said: “I consider legislation, all legislation when it comes before me. The people of Wide Bay have sent me here to do the right thing by them.

“I’ve got a strong track record when it comes to standing up – I was the person that told the Prime Minister in the last term that I would support a royal commission into the banks,” he told Sky.

In a sign of how dysfunctional McCormack’s party room has become, Ken O’Dowd – who is deputy whip and thus supposedly has a role in enforcing discipline – told the ABC he voted for O’Brien.

O’Dowd explained this by saying that like him, O’Brien was a Queenslander, and Queenslanders were under-represented on McCormack’s frontbench. “Fortune favours the brave. … Good on the underdog.”

O’Dowd ran unsuccessfully against Drum at Monday’s Nationals meeting to be the government’s nominee for the deputy speakership.

He said Joyce had been planning to nominate him for the position when the parliamentary vote came but he had told Joyce not to do so, in the name of unity. He also indicated he would like to see Joyce leader “one day, if the chips are right”.

Meanwhile the “coal wars” flared, fuelled by the government’s weekend confirmation of the feasibility study for a coal-fired power station in Queensland and the allocation of $4 million for it.

Liberals Dave Sharma and Trent Zimmerman said the government should not fund a coal-fired power station.

Queensland National and former resources minister Matt Canavan, who resigned from cabinet last week to support Joyce’s tilt at the leadership, tweeted: “I see some are saying that we should not help coal fired power stations provide jobs because we should leave it to the market. Well if that’s the view be consistent and argue against the billions we give to renewables every year!”

George Christensen, another National from Queensland, said in a blog: “Despite claims by one inner-city Liberal MP on Sky News this morning, the Morrison Liberal National Government is providing funding to coal-fired power projects, principally because they provide stable and reliable baseload supply.

“When the Collinsville clean coal-fired power project is ready to be constructed, it will be eligible for consideration under the Morrison Liberal National government’s Underwriting New Generation Investments program, which supports targeted investment that will lower prices, increase competition and increase reliability in the energy system.”

Just to add to the toxic day, Malcolm Turnbull – in Canberra for the Widodo speech to parliament – had a few succinct thoughts to contribute.

“The fundamental economic reality is this … there is no economic basis on which to build a coal-fired power station in Australia any longer. … Those people who are advocating that the government should fund coal-fired power are basically making a case for higher emissions and higher energy prices and that is nuts,” he said.

He might have added that what’s going on inside the Nationals is pretty much nuts too.

Michelle Grattan is a professorial fellow at the University of Canberra. This article was originally published on The Conversation

Who Can You Trust?

In a world beleaguered by spin and confused messages, there's never been more need for diverse, trustworthy, independent journalism in Canberra.

Who can you trust? Well, for more than 25 years, "CityNews" has proudly been an independent, free, family-owned news magazine, serving the national capital with quality, integrity and authority. Through our weekly magazine and daily through our digital platforms, we constantly and reliably deliver high-quality and diverse opinion, news, arts, socials and lifestyle columns.

If you trust our work online and believe in the power of independent voices, I encourage you to make a small contribution.

Every dollar of support will be invested back into our journalism so we can continue to provide a valuably different view of what's happening around you and keep free.

Click here to make your donation and you will be supporting the future of journalism and media diversity in the ACT.

Thank you,

Ian Meikle, editor

Previous articleMan injured in Gordon shooting
Next articleNew fire cameras help with early detection
Michelle Grattan
Professorial Fellow, University of Canberra, Michelle Grattan is one of Australia's most respected and awarded political journalists.

Leave a Reply