News location:

Wednesday, November 27, 2024 | Digital Edition | Crossword & Sudoku

‘Children are dying, you’re the health minister…’

It was another busy day at Canberra Hospital’s Eventually Department when KEEPING UP THE ACT popped in… see the latest column here

Dead children and a health minister very publicly dodging questions about a hospital system the ACT government has shamefully underfunded for years; does it get any worse for this community? It’s “Seven Days” with IAN MEIKLE.

“PEOPLE die in hospitals. It is part of delivering a hospital service.” And there, with chilling clinical indifference, the health minister confirmed to the nation the shameful state of emergency care in the ACT. 

Ian Meikle.

That line, from Rachel Stephen-Smith’s appearance at the August 23 estimates hearing, was beamed to every corner of our wide, brown land in a damning indictment on the treatment and deaths recently of two young people – first, five-year-old Rozalia Spadafora and more recently Brian Lovelock, 13 – in hospital.

Avoidable deaths? That’s for the coroner to ultimately decide, but the story on “A Current Affair” made for uncomfortable viewing; two sobbing mothers contrasted with Stephen-Smith, virtuously wearing a mask as she strode silently across Civic Square stalked by a persistent “ACA” reporter asking, not unreasonably after four requests for an interview, why the minister wouldn’t talk to her.

To the reporter’s question: “Children are dying, you’re the health minister, what are you doing about it?”. Stephen-Smith, through her mask, had the gall to say: “I would strongly recommend that you think about the way you are presenting this story.” 

Guaranteed broadcast and high-fives in the Sydney editing suite, but a revealing glimpse for wider Australia of an arrogant government minister in an arrogant, tired government too used to compliance from sections of the local media. 

Tone deaf, she marched on ignoring the reporter’s insistent questioning until, as she was about to disappear down a staircase, she was asked if she had anything to say to the bereaved families. The mask dropped and there was a tremulous apology. Of sorts. 

Two days later, Leon Delaney, on 2CC’s “Canberra Live” drive program, took the minister to the observation of Prof Walter Abhayaratna, AMA ACT president, that there were some changes to the hospital’s early warning pediatric protocols that could be “implemented immediately”.

“I don’t think Walter is right about this. I’m going to be blunt. I don’t think he is reporting this issue fairly,” she said. 

Well, of course, what would Walter know, anyway? He only practices at Canberra Hospital and isn’t briefed to any level like the minister is. 

Rachel Stephen-Smith on “ACA”.

“I really would emphasise that there is, in fact, no completed investigation that indicates that the actions of Canberra Hospital resulted… was contributing to the eventual outcome,” she blundered on.

That would be because the coroner is looking at it and is probably months and months away from forming any view?

Then when Delaney got to the question of empathy, we broadly discovered she hasn’t got any. She sent the grieving family of the five-year-old an email of sympathy. An email, sweet Jesus!

A simple message offering the opportunity of a meeting is not a difficult thing to do, mused Delaney?

“I think it’s very easy to say that in hindsight, but it would not be the normal thing to do [children dying in these circumstances in our hospitals is “normal”, minister?].”

Then it got worse: “The thing that really frustrated me about this is Ms Castley met with the family; she appears to have known they were expecting some senior outreach from me or the CEO or chief operating officer at the Canberra Hospital.”

Ms Castley is Leanne Castley, the opposition health shadow, suddenly dragged into the interview.

“She didn’t tell me that. She waited a week. She didn’t pick up the phone to me to say, hey, the family’s in distress, this family needs support. 

“She knew that before it was in the media. She’s got my phone number; she didn’t call me, she didn’t text me; she didn’t send me an email.”

Well, boo-hoo-hoo, Rachel. With all the resources of the Health Directorate, you’re calling out a fellow member of the Legislative Assembly for having the wit to come down from the ivory tower and demonstrate empathy to a grieving family. 

At the end of the “ACA” report, anchor Tracy Grimshaw intoned that the chief minister was standing by the health minister and the ACT government would wait for recommendations from the coroner before making any changes to the health service… 

Just as Skills Minister Chris Steel won’t do anything about the CIT until the Integrity Commission reports; just as Corrections Minister Mick Gentlemen won’t act on allegations of drug parties among prison staff until the Integrity Commission reports. 

AND through all this, Health Minister Stephen-Smith is enjoying a pay rise to $301,070. 

Mind you, it took the community weeks, no, months, to discover the political class has been quietly given a pretty tasty pay increase. 

Compliments of the media-shy Independent Remuneration Tribunal, members of the ACT Legislative Assembly got a 3.25 per cent lift from July 1. 

That means we are now paying a base, annual salary for backbenchers of $177,100 (up $6000). 

Andrew Barr gets a $11.5k leg up as chief minister with his salary now tipping $371,910 and Opposition Leader Elizabeth Lee takes home $301,070.

And while your eyebrows are up: Deputy Chief Minister Yvette Berry is on $318,780 and Deputy Opposition Leader Jeremy Hanson trousers $212,520.

The head of the ACT public service Kathy Leigh, she who – eight years in the job – was unable to answer the Liberals’ question about how many times maladministration, corruption or fraud was reported to her as required under the ACT Public Sector Management Act at the recent estimates hearings, is now enjoying $434,014 a year. That’s $62,104 more than her boss, the chief minister. 

Ian Meikle is the editor of “CityNews” and can be heard with Rod Henshaw on the “CityNews Sunday Roast” news and interview program, 2CC, 9am-noon. There are more of his columns on citynews.com.au

 

Who can be trusted?

In a world of spin and confusion, there’s never been a more important time to support independent journalism in Canberra.

If you trust our work online and want to enforce the power of independent voices, I invite you to make a small contribution.

Every dollar of support is invested back into our journalism to help keep citynews.com.au strong and free.

Become a supporter

Thank you,

Ian Meikle, editor

Ian Meikle

Ian Meikle

Share this

4 Responses to ‘Children are dying, you’re the health minister…’

G Hollands says: 12 September 2022 at 10:58 am

Wow, that much money and there are still many dangerous potholes on Canberra roads! These people could not organise a chook raffle. Once again I ask, how is it that the Canberra electorate continues to be snowed by a bunch of incompetents. Please use your vote wisely at the next election.

Reply
Jane says: 12 September 2022 at 12:11 pm

“ ‘PEOPLE die in hospitals. It is part of delivering a hospital service.’ And there, with chilling clinical indifference, the health minister confirmed to the nation the shameful state of emergency care in the ACT.”
I’m sorry Ian I can’t, and I don’t, agree with you on this occasion.
Sad as it is, what the Health Minister said is true. Every day, people young and old, go into hospitals all over the country, and the world, and sadly, don’t come out. It doesn’t happen just in the ACT.
It’s not only part of “delivering a hospital service”, it’s a part of life, and an indisputable fact.

Reply
Trevor says: 12 September 2022 at 1:32 pm

Jane, you are right that it is unavoidable that people die in hospital and that it happens all the time. But what the columnist is talking about is preventable death. We’ve already had two ACT coroner’s reports on deaths from bacterial infections that shouldn’t have occurred and now two further deaths that also appear to have been preventable. And these were all otherwise healthy kids, not people with existing health issues.

It’s a fair call to accept that someone may die after the hospital did everything in their power to save them. It’s another story if they died of a cause that could have, and should have, been prevented. That our Health Minister blasély accepts these preventable deaths as “business as usual” and sees no need for change is shameful.

Reply
Randal Anderson says: 15 September 2022 at 10:34 pm

I have just left Canberra Hospital after a 14 day stay with a broken ankle. I have no complaints about my medical care from the doctors and the nursing staff who were excellent and friendly. However, in the 14 days I was there my room was not cleaned once. My wife cleaned and sanitised the tray table which was very dirty. The floor of the room was never swept or vacuumed nor any of the hard surfaces sprayed or sanitised. The only cleaning staff I saw pushed a scissor broom through the wards but never came past the curtain line of the room. They also emptied the waste bins. A final point, the meal trays were not always clean. An urgent review of the cleaning contract should be done. It could identify the source of the bacterial infections.

Reply

Leave a Reply

Related Posts

Opinion

KEEPING UP THE ACT

Okay, kids, let's all sing along to Canberra's favourite transport song, Chris Steel on the Bus (goes round and round).

Follow us on Instagram @canberracitynews