News location:

Thursday, November 28, 2024 | Digital Edition | Crossword & Sudoku

Tower plan crowds in smaller Civic unit block

A close perspective where the proposed Geocon towers will be located in relation to the Forum Apartments.

“When a development happens to be on a site under the supervision of the National Capital Authority, things really get messy! This is what is being played out with a massive Geocon three-tower development in Civic being considered by the NCA,” writes “Canberra Matters” columnist PAUL COSTIGAN

IN this city with the ever-increasing towers, as encouraged by the developer-friendly chief minister, the major issue is not just the towers themselves, but the lack of planning guiding the appropriateness and logic of their size and the location.

Paul Costigan.

Along Northbourne Avenue and in Woden, the tower development goes on regardless of community voices that have said we can do better than this.

Residents keep pointing out that apartment developments should be guided by good design (what used to be architecture) and the allocation of spaces around the apartments for open green spaces, trees (shade) and community facilities (landscape architecture). 

It is about the health and well-being of residents in tower blocks. Despite this being obvious and frequently covered by the media during this pandemic, open-space areas and facilities are rarely adequate with the developments along Northbourne Avenue and those in the Woden Town Centre.

When a development happens to be on a site under the supervision of the National Capital Authority (NCA), things really get messy! This is what is being played out with a massive Geocon three-tower development in Civic being considered by the NCA.

The five-storey Forum Apartments have been in quiet residence for about 20 years opposite the Civic Pool on 66 Allara Street, situated down the southern end before the walkway over the Commonwealth Park.

Recently Geocon announced, with heaps of positive local media, that it had applied to the NCA to build three towers next to The Forum. These towers, two being nine storeys and one seven storeys (on top of car parks), will surround the Forum Apartments on their west and southern sides.

Red area is where the proposed Geocon towers will be located, in front and beside the Forum Apartments.

Residents are wondering whether the NCA has any interest in ensuring that the west-facing Forum apartments should continue to have effective solar access – so much so that heating is minimal on the good days. This solar access will disappear if the NCA approves this Geocon development proposal without serious amendments.

Likewise, the narrow lane that is the entrance to The Forum carpark for its 117 apartments, will have to meet the huge increase in usage from the residents of the 357 apartments. 

Given how many people with vehicles occupy such dwellings, this small lane will have to function well above the original expectations. 

As with recent apartments built under the present ad hoc planning regime, there will be substantial overflow parking. The pool’s car park opposite will be the obvious target for these residents seeking somewhere to park.

The placement of a tower so close to an established set of apartments (at one point 13 metres) should not be allowed.

Sadly, this is now normal for this city where the rules are made and bent to suit the big developers – not the residents.

The submission for these towers has the usual lightly coloured pleasing “artist impressions” of the final development. Groups of happy people are milling about, trees everywhere and there are site angles that disguise the comparison between the new lofty towers and the Forum Apartments and the other buildings close by. Amazingly misleading!

In a city where real planning happens, the block to the west of The Forum would be used for a common area – a parkland with facilities and places to rest outside. The two towers to the south would be reduced to fit in with the character of the other developments. 

This change, besides doing wonderful things for all the residents, would provide a much more aesthetically pleasing view from nearby National Circuit. 

Given this a national capital issue, one hopes that all the local federal politicians will engage with the residents to influence the decisions of the NCA.

The Forum residents have come together and are very active about this development proposal. They have contacted a raft of politicians and others to get those in power positions to understand that there is a better solution here rather then the developer business as usual approach. There is! 

Will the NCA see this and bring about a better urban environment for the present Forum residents as well as the new residents in the yet to be built apartments?

Who can be trusted?

In a world of spin and confusion, there’s never been a more important time to support independent journalism in Canberra.

If you trust our work online and want to enforce the power of independent voices, I invite you to make a small contribution.

Every dollar of support is invested back into our journalism to help keep citynews.com.au strong and free.

Become a supporter

Thank you,

Ian Meikle, editor

Paul Costigan

Paul Costigan

Share this

8 Responses to Tower plan crowds in smaller Civic unit block

Colin Smeal says: 19 February 2022 at 7:52 am

Given the NCAs record there is little hope that they might start to consider the residents and people of Canberra when it comes to these inappropriate developments. Sad isn’t it?

Reply
S. Draw, K. Cab says: 19 February 2022 at 12:42 pm

…very sad. What’s left to be done. Public nuisance outside Barr’s house?

Maybe a large collective could buy a block north neighbouring his house and put in a DA for some large units (minimum X4 and 3 floors tall)

Reply
James says: 19 February 2022 at 3:37 pm

Are you arguing that Allara Street isn’t the place for higher density development? It is walking distance to one of the biggest employment and retail precincts between Sydney and Melbourne, so I’d have to disagree. Perhaps it’s the lack of green space? You can walk to Commonwealth Park in two minutes. But what about parking my car? I think we’ve already agreed that you can walk most places. I know you’ve got beef with the planning system, Paul, but this one’s not the hill to die on.

Reply
S. Draw, K. Cab says: 20 February 2022 at 9:50 am

not answering for Paul, but I don’t think he was saying that all higher density was wrong for that site. As is often done, this just becomes the straw-man argument.

Reply
James says: 21 February 2022 at 11:48 am

I understand, and I agree that a nuanced discussion is needed, but i’m afraid this isn’t the forum since my original comment has already been partly redacted…

Reply
Ian Meikle says: 21 February 2022 at 12:04 pm

James made some good points in his comment and these were published. I removed derogatory comments of the column’s author, which were extraneous to the discussion.

Greg Hollands says: 19 February 2022 at 1:56 pm

And, of course, there is no consideration of the future developments in the same area! The Civic Pool has been under siege for many years. You will also recall that the ACT Govt announced a joint venture with the UNSW for the development of the car parks all the way down Constitution Ave. What are they contemplating there?

Reply

Leave a Reply

Related Posts

Opinion

KEEPING UP THE ACT

Okay, kids, let's all sing along to Canberra's favourite transport song, Chris Steel on the Bus (goes round and round).

Follow us on Instagram @canberracitynews