News location:

Sunday, September 8, 2024 | Digital Edition | Crossword & Sudoku

Warning rate rise would ‘pull the rug out’ from economy

Reserve Bank Building, London Circuit, Canberra
“Any further increase in interest rates cannot be justified, and would just pull the rug out from under a cautious economic recovery,” said Deloitte Access economist Stephen Smith.

By Jacob Shteyman in Canberra

A further rise in interest rates can’t be justified despite inflation retreating slower than hoped, economists have argued as key decisions loom.

June quarter inflation data, due to be released by the Australian Bureau of Statistics on Wednesday, marks the start of an important few weeks for the Australian economy.

Deloitte Access Economics partners Stephen Smith and Cathryn Lee believe it represents a fork in the road for policymakers.

A benign readout could lead to the Reserve Bank board holding rates steady again when it meets in August, while an upside inflation surprise could force its hand to lift rates again, they said in their quarterly Business Outlook report.

But a return to monetary tightening would be misguided, the pair argues.

“Any further increase in interest rates cannot be justified, and would just pull the rug out from under a cautious economic recovery,” Mr Smith said.

“Should rates stay on hold, the narrative of a strengthening Australian economy through the second half of 2024 would remain intact.”

The report acknowledges it is not a view wholly shared by the Australian economic commentariat.

Judo Bank’s Warren Hogan, Coolabah Capital’s Christopher Joye and the ANU’s Stephen Hamilton have all argued the RBA has undercooked the cash rate, pointing to sticky inflation and persistently high employment.

At four per cent, the unemployment rate remains well below pre-covid levels, which would suggest a relatively robust economy.

But Mr Smith said low unemployment was not as helpful an indicator as it seemed.

The robust jobs figures were largely due to employment growth in non-market sectors, such as health and disability services, which were not typically associated with a booming economy.

Mr Smith pointed to sluggish GDP growth as further proof the economy was not overheating.

Inflation would not be curtailed by a further rise in interest rates, which worked by slowing excess demand, he said.

He expected the economy to grow by just one per cent in 2024 and argued other factors were contributing to inflation, such as a housing shortage pushing up rents.

“None of this sort of inflation will be tamed by higher interest rates,” Mr Smith said.

There are plenty of economists who agree the case for rate rises has passed.

All of the big four banks predict the next rate move will be downward, although later than initially forecast, while State Street Global Advisors economist Krishna Bhimavarapu warned another interest rate rise could plunge already feeble economic growth into recession territory.

“We still think a rate hike will be a policy mistake, as the economy is at a tipping point, where the unemployment rate could rise beyond their comfort level,” he said.

Who can be trusted?

In a world of spin and confusion, there’s never been a more important time to support independent journalism in Canberra.

If you trust our work online and want to enforce the power of independent voices, I invite you to make a small contribution.

Every dollar of support is invested back into our journalism to help keep citynews.com.au strong and free.

Become a supporter

Thank you,

Ian Meikle, editor

Share this

2 Responses to Warning rate rise would ‘pull the rug out’ from economy

cbrapsycho says: 25 July 2024 at 9:45 am

It takes very twisted thinking to claim that higher unemployment is good for our economy, let alone our society. The higher the unemployment rate, the higher the poverty rate and the crime rate and thus the higher the cost of welfare, of health services, of policing and imprisonment as well as many other taxpayer funded services. Economists need to look at our society as a whole rather than narrowly focussing on isolated indicators.

Reply
David says: 25 July 2024 at 12:14 pm

Added to that they need to be focused on the cause and not the effect. Chalmers is the problem and the RBA is just responding to how he is leading the economy. I bet he’s hoping they go up so he has another excuse to transfer tax payers money into property investors pockets through more rental assistance, Nothing like teasing those struggling on the way through as it goes in one hand and out the other. Here, have some tax payer money to give to the rich.

Reply

Leave a Reply

Related Posts

Follow us on Instagram @canberracitynews