News location:

Friday, November 15, 2024 | Digital Edition | Crossword & Sudoku

Perhaps the answer’s hiding in plain sight

Cartoon: Paul Dorin

“Maybe our species is not fit for purpose – perhaps hard fact and comforting fiction are inseparable in the human psyche; and our time in the universe will be as fleeting as a passing shadow,” writes “The Gadfly” columnist ROBERT MACKLIN

MY old French master, with his quiet smile at the double entendre, told us: “Words have gender; people have sex”. 

Robert Macklin.

It was a nice line – memorable but inoffensive, instructive but debatable. However, it was the following questions and answers that have kept the memory fresh. Everyone had a go and we walked away feeling pretty good.

Today, while the ballooning world population affirms that people still indeed have sex, they also share the “gender” marker with the written, spoken (and shouted) word. In fact, “gender”, “sexual preference” and a growing alphabetical list of hormonal predilections have expanded the vocab far beyond the old English master’s imagining.

At the same time, we’re engaged in a worldwide revolution to recognise and redeem the behaviour of those on the male side of the hormonal spectrum towards the female of the species. 

What in the master’s day was laughingly called “the battle of the sexes” is a laughing matter no more. For months, it seems, the Parliament has been obsessed with it.

It comes just as two other existential issues bear down upon us – the weird 20th century-style war in Ukraine, which could so easily turn nuclear; and the almost inevitable runaway heating of the globe leading to mass extinction, perhaps even of our own role as the apex predator. 

Our responses to these threats do not bode well. Dictator Putin is downloading his atomic warheads to his thuggish enforcer in Belarus. This will give him the squeak of deniability should one of them “accidentally” explode over Kyiv. 

The bodies of hundreds – soon to be thousands – of climate escapees are piling up in the depths of the Mediterranean as our fellow “people smugglers” enrich themselves with their victims’ plight. 

Others of similar ilk are feeding an insatiable addiction to escape reality with the illusion provided by cocaine, heroin, alcohol, speed, LSD or anything else that offers surcease from the normality of an earlier age.

Across the Pacific the gun-crazy, evangelical Americans are shooting each other in schools and businesses as they’re forced to choose a president between a kindly old dodderer and a rabble-rousing conman. They’re threatening war with our biggest trading partner, which is run by a pretend emperor, while Xi Jinping himself uses provincial Taiwan as a symbol of his historical magnificence… as though history really gives a damn.

In the middle of all this, we’ve finally begun to realise the shocking pain of dispossession us whitefellas imposed on the Aboriginal people who had lived in relative harmony with the natural world from time immemorial. 

And a new government is taking the first step in a healing process called the Voice to Parliament (together, alas, with the lawyerly “and the executive government”).

It feels like we’re fighting on all fronts while blinded by the smoke of a raging bushfire… and our usual weapons of informational force majeure are scattered to the four wild winds of social media. 

Perhaps the answer is hiding in plain sight. To engage it depends on our willingness to step back from the chaos and seek the common denominator that connects them. 

Perhaps the old English master touched a hopeful chord, one that spoke thoughtfully, humorously and a little provocatively, of the rules we make to navigate our way through our brief span of communal life. At least we listened to the questions and answers.

But maybe our species is not fit for purpose – perhaps hard fact and comforting fiction are inseparable in the human psyche; and our time in the universe will be as fleeting as a passing shadow. 

robert@robertmacklin.com

 

Who can be trusted?

In a world of spin and confusion, there’s never been a more important time to support independent journalism in Canberra.

If you trust our work online and want to enforce the power of independent voices, I invite you to make a small contribution.

Every dollar of support is invested back into our journalism to help keep citynews.com.au strong and free.

Become a supporter

Thank you,

Ian Meikle, editor

Robert Macklin

Robert Macklin

Share this

One Response to Perhaps the answer’s hiding in plain sight

cbrapsycho says: 29 June 2023 at 10:27 am

Wonderful article that clearly identifies the problem! ‘perhaps hard fact and comforting fiction are inseparable in the human psyche’.

Many people confuse fact and fiction as they don’t know how to separate the two, often because their beliefs and emotions automatically lead them to follow previous ways of thinking and acting. When life is confusing we fall back on what we know, rather than seeking new ways of understanding things. It is a quick way of reducing mental discomfort (or cognitive dissonance) and increasing confidence in knowing what to think or do.

In our world, there is a common lack of skill in critical thinking and analysis, meaning that many people cannot see the difference between fact and opinion. People often think that their assumptions and conclusions are proven facts, when they’re inferences made in the absence of sufficient facts.

Our discomfort with uncertainty means filling these information gaps with our personal beliefs based on our personal experience, which is completely subjective. We make assumptions to give us confidence we’re on the right track and we seek support from others with similar opinions to boost that confidence in our beliefs. Then we act on them, looking for confirmation but not seeking contradictory information to ascertain the truth. This leads to confirmation bias.

Personally, I believe that our species is fit for purpose, as this is an issue of learning and skill building. There are people who can see both confirmatory and contradictory information, as they’ve worked hard to gain critical thinking skills to sort through the morass of often conflicting data. They are not black and white thinkers, being able to see different shades of grey as well as a range of other colours. They are more able to deal with the complexity that shapes our world and is part of every wicked problem. Most people are capable of gaining these skills to see things more clearly but it requires considerable effort and discipline to apply them when or where emotions are strongly influencing the desired outcome.

Reply

Leave a Reply

Related Posts

Follow us on Instagram @canberracitynews