News location:

Friday, November 15, 2024 | Digital Edition | Crossword & Sudoku

Canberra’s cooked, the Barr-becue has to end

Chief Minister Andrew Barr… “timid as a mouse, when the Feds are turning the War Memorial into a sideshow of weaponry, normalising if not promoting the obscenity of war.” Photo: Holly Treadaway

“It’s this pathetic attachment to ‘growth’ as the economic miracle-maker that Barr is using to destroy the quality of life that made living here such a pleasure,” writes “The Gadfly” columnist ROBERT MACKLIN

ONE of the rare pleasures of the pandemic has been the chance to get to know the national capital’s hidden delights, especially the nature walks and picnic spots. 

Robert Macklin.

Last weekend at one of the best – Dairy Farmers Hill in the Arboretum – came a revelation: it’s time to vote the Barr Labor government out of office.

The hill commands the most delightful view of Canberra, bar none. On this day, the lake was a shimmering wonder from the foreshore of Yarralumla, across the wide reaches past Morrison’s folly, the Queen Elizabeth II islet, under the bridges Commonwealth and King, and away to the Molonglo with the midday sun flashing off the aluminum triangle above Parliament House.

From this angle and at this height, it’s a scene that would make Walter Burley and Marion Griffin weep with joy. But when you work your way around the lookout, the sudden reality of the Barr government’s vision of the capital’s future glares back at you. Everywhere you look you see the mad expansion designed for his Canberra of endless growth as he calls for a huge increase in immigration.

And though his foolish obsession with the tramline of 19th century technology is hidden behind Black Mountain, its raison d’etre, of catering for endless suburban development, is everywhere you look. New suburbs named Whitlam and Throsby (discoverer of the Limestone Plains) and Taylor (who knows?) are being torn out of the landscape, all designed for Macmansions to house the migrant influx.

It’s this pathetic attachment to “growth” as the economic miracle-maker that Barr is using to destroy the quality of life that made living here such a pleasure, and that delighted visitors on their journeys to the cultural heart of the nation with free access to the National Gallery and the solemn memorial to the servicemen and women who gave their lives in the horrors of war. That’s the way it was when Barr took over from Chief Ministers Jon Stanhope and Katy Gallagher in 2014. 

It was Stanhope who sponsored the magnificent Arboretum – against much opposition – that is now Canberra’s crowning glory. And it was Katy who carried her Labor convictions into the Senate where time and again she has exposed the profligacies and incompetence of Morrison government ministers. 

But Barr, alas, is a convert to the neo-liberalism that uses massive increases in rates, parking fees and stamp duties to finance his tramlines when electric buses made much more sense then, and especially now when public servants are working from home. 

And it’s Barr, timid as a mouse, when the Feds are turning the War Memorial into a sideshow of weaponry, normalising if not promoting the obscenity of war.

He even set forth to buy NSW land beyond the ACT boundaries to feed the developmental frenzy. 

The result, already, is overcrowded roads, complaints of suburban potholes and overgrowth of the undergrowth in many of those nature walks and picnic places that provided us with relief from the confines of home in the seemingly endless battle against covid.

Labor has been in office, mostly with Greens’ support, for two decades and that alone should be enough to demand a change of government. 

Indeed, these days the Greens’ leader Shane Rattenbury has been totally subsumed into the Barr-becue, a mere sausage among the Labor chops. And since none of them are obvious chef material, and the Libs are split between right and extreme right, perhaps it’s time for a local version of the Rise of the Independents to step up to the Barr.

robert@robertmacklin.com 

Who can be trusted?

In a world of spin and confusion, there’s never been a more important time to support independent journalism in Canberra.

If you trust our work online and want to enforce the power of independent voices, I invite you to make a small contribution.

Every dollar of support is invested back into our journalism to help keep citynews.com.au strong and free.

Become a supporter

Thank you,

Ian Meikle, editor

Robert Macklin

Robert Macklin

Share this

20 Responses to Canberra’s cooked, the Barr-becue has to end

Julio says: 1 February 2022 at 9:51 am

For what it’s worth, Robert, this town now has a vibrancy it never had before. It was unsustainable and heavily subsidised by the rest of the country. Now it’s an economic powerhouse.

Also, Griffin wanted medium density housing but was overruled by the public servants.

Reply
S. Draw, K. Cab says: 1 February 2022 at 11:47 am

* vibrancy = traffic? Have you seen the building quality in Gungahlin and new Stromlo valley suburbs?

* powerhouse? Based solely on leveraging ever higher LVT based rates? We’ll have to move out of our suburb given past raises applied to future prices. How’s that a progressive tax Rachel Something-Something-Smith? Apparently you have to be rich to live in a “rich” suburb.

*medium density housing? straw-man argument. Who said you can’t have medium density housing that is interesting, tasteful and sensitive to the landscape? Yet, we have the exact opposite. Paul Costigan’s been on this for years with a bazillion examples.

Are you in the same city Julio?

+1 for EVERYTHING Robert Macklin said.

Anyone but Labor (Greens), or Libs. ANYONE! Independents, Canberra Progressives, A N Y O N E.

People, you DO have alternatives. Hullo, H U L L O is anyone home McFly?!

Reply
Sam says: 1 February 2022 at 11:58 am

I agree Julio, I am enjoying the way Canberra is evolving while keeping a lot of the good parts. Canberra is growing up as a city rather than staying as a large country town.

Reply
Tony says: 8 February 2022 at 7:31 pm

The planners of what Canberra is today back in the 1960s and 70s also wanted more medium/high density development even back then (they cited the design of paris as a good example of denser development making for a more functional city) but at the time the federal government was trying to entice public servants to move to Canberra from Melbourne and it was noted that melburnians who lived in detached, low-density housing were unlikely to move unless they could get a detached house in Canberra.

This is why we are stuck with the city layout we have, before Belco/Woden etc. were built it could’ve been different.

Reply
Roberto Roberts says: 1 February 2022 at 3:06 pm

The tram supports suburbanisation? Rates and stamp duty are neoliberalism? The ACT government can control immigration? What a ridiculous article.

There’s more to quality of life than a lack of traffic, and many bigger, better cities than Canberra have lovely nature walks and picnic spots.

Reply
steve Tran says: 1 February 2022 at 3:28 pm

Federal election soon. Tell Labor to get rid of Labor (and barking dogs) or else… I’m going for the Flat Earth Party so we push a few have-beens off the edge. The Greens do sweet nuffin. Good article Rob

Reply
Erin says: 1 February 2022 at 3:38 pm

“New suburbs named Whitlam and Throsby (discoverer of the Limestone Plains) and Taylor (who knows?)”

Taylor is named for Australia’s first female architect! Mary Florence Taylor.

Reply
Doug Jackson says: 1 February 2022 at 3:47 pm

What idiots our politicians must be…..

Purchasing land from NSW far to the ACT’s North, the place where the roads are narrower than a Melbourne alleyway.

Building houses on the long covered rubbish dumps where foundations will surely crack.

Building homes on top of the old Naval station in Belconnen, where pits were full of PCB’s from the high voltage transformers.

Building houses on top of the buffer land along the Molonglo river, where the overflow from Googong dam passes after it goes through Lake Burley Griffin. One day there will be a *big* flood.

There is a heap of quality land here in the ACT – Extend the suburban development south past Banks, past Tharwa. Or are we frightened that the coveted tram will never make it that far?

Reply
Tony says: 8 February 2022 at 7:25 pm

It is interesting to look at how far Tuggeranong was supposed to extend, with Tharwa being surrounded by suburbia and further development on the other side of the murrumbidgee river.

Many people are aware (some may not be) that the reason the Tuggeranong town centre was established on the western side of Tuggers is because that area was supposed to be right in the middle with more suburbs to the west (and further south).

Reply
Hamba says: 1 February 2022 at 3:57 pm

I LOL every time some some writer opines about how nasty Labor and the Greens are … and then concludes by calling for a ‘Rise of the Independents’. That’s the exact recipe that keeps returning Labor and the Greens to government.

Reply
Rob Hayes says: 1 February 2022 at 5:44 pm

All I can say if you don’t like it or are not happy you could move to some where better( if you an find it.) I moved to Canberra as an apprentice when the rest of the country had little to no promising work and have been here since. All I can say to you Robert is to just keep writing your books or you could move back to Brisbane Thanks all

Reply
Neil, of Queanbeyan says: 1 February 2022 at 10:32 pm

Usually I agree wholeheartedly with Paul Costigan but rarely with Robert Macklin. This time Macklin has got it right, but at least a couple of elections after it was obvious. Unfortunately the people of Canberra are not smart enough to get rid of Barr, Rattenbury and the other vandals. That’s why we are now living in Queanbeyan and loving it. As Butcher Lindbeck had on his window the day we moved here, “Proudly not Ken Behrens!”.

Reply
Brian says: 2 February 2022 at 6:56 am

All the major parties are wedded to endless growth. Their donors are the few financial beneficiaries of endless growth. Developers, banks etc. The reason big business is keen to get back to big migration is that the endless pressure on the supply side of the labour market keeps wages down and grows their profits for zero competition.

Politicians love it because it produces a headline GDP growth figure (migrants have to consume) even while real GDP per capita declines and lived experiences in our major cities degrades. The federal government sets the migration figure but the states have to build out most of the infrastructure and services for the new arrivals. Based on whose estimate you use, we are 700B behind in that build out and will never catch up if excessive migration is resumed.

The other myth is that we have high skilled migration. We don’t. The average wage of a migrant is less than the average wage of an incumbent Australian so on average migrants cannot be high skilled. If we were serious about having high skilled migrants we would move the floor wage from 54K to 80+K as a base to *start* to get skilled migration.

The other myth is the skills shortage. Think about it. We have had a decade or more of Net Overseas Migration exceeding 200+K and a similar period with up to 900K intl students studying in the country, many with a path to citizenship yet we have a skills shortage? Either the migration program or the uni System is not fit for purpose or both.

Reply
Phil says: 7 February 2022 at 12:59 pm

I agree with your conclusion about ACT Labour/Greens government Rob, but your logic and arguments seem to be a window into your level of privilege. You see over development, i see rising homelessness, a lack of affordable housing and people being exploited by rent seeking housing investors and established owners in a broken housing market. Where you point out traffic congestion, potholes and nature walk conditions, i point to worsening inequality, intergenerational theft and elite rent seeking facilitated by morally bankrupt self serving politicians threatens to undermine the prosperity and freedom of current and future Australians. The development and growth you decry is driven by the intersection of vested interests seeking government guaranteed profits, and the fact that if the population grows as lobbied for growth hungry business, then people have to live somewhere proximate to where they can earn a living.

Reply
Tony says: 8 February 2022 at 7:20 pm

You should read a book published by the NCDC in 1970 titled Tomorrow’s Canberra.

Canberra was supposed to reach 500,000 people by 1992 and exceed well over one million by now after expanding beyond the NSW border to the north and over into the Kowen forest in the east.

Canberra’s population growth slowed down significantly from the late 60s and early 70s when it was at 10 percent per year.

Of course, it was always intended to slow down from 10 percent to a more reasonable number, but in fact it slowed and stalled much more than originally planned.

The reason our existing town centres such and Woden and Tuggeranong have been stagnating and suffering is because the population of these areas never reached the levels expected.

Canberra as a whole is much smaller and less significant/important than it should be.

Reply
TT says: 9 February 2022 at 11:08 am

What about the dodgy extension at regatta point! Another lost opportunity for a landmark like arboretum. Short sighted and does not match the iconic landmarks like national libtary, museum and high court. So disappointing.

Reply
Pete says: 17 February 2022 at 2:09 pm

Proudly left Canberra for good 4 years ago. I had lived there since my teens and have seen it become an absolutely horrendous urban sprawl through Belconnen, Tuggeranong, and the hideously ugly Gunghalin. Pretty much every suburb looks the same.

Increased crime and panhandlers in the city, 6-figure public servants stroll past and ignore the homeless while sipping their lattes and laughing. The division between the rich and the poor is so noticeable now.

Canberra is a bubble of over-superannuated lanyard-wearing whingers growing fat and lazy on the taxes of ordinary citizens. That’s the way it has always been. A never-never land of public servants hanging out and waiting for their next pay increment.

Boiling hot in Summer. Freezing cold in winter. Worst drivers in Australia.

Oh but hey – how about that Arboretum ?

Reply

Leave a Reply

Related Posts

Follow us on Instagram @canberracitynews