Scales of justice lose balance

Share Canberra's trusted news:

THERE are times when our legal system gets so caught up in its own rules, manners and precedents that it loses sight of its essential role in the community – to balance the scales of justice. This was never more strikingly illustrated than in the case of the Crowley family of Chapman.

Jonathan Crowley
Jonathan Crowley
By now most Canberrans will be aware of the general outlines of the case.

On December 11, 2001 Jonathan Crowley, then 34, lost touch with reality and was walking the streets of Chapman chanting religious slogans and wielding a kendo stick. Two policemen were called to the scene and when their capsicum spray failed to subdue him one of them shot him in the neck. Jonathan was rendered quadriplegic.

His family launched a civil proceeding against ACT Mental Health (ACTMH) and the Australian Federal Police seeking compensation. Ten years later they won their case when Justice Penfold awarded them $8 million on the grounds that both organisations had breached their duty of care to the patient.

Then, in December, in a shock decision the ACT Court of Appeals struck down Justice Penfold’s decision. Because the Government had appealed, the Crowleys had not received any of the money awarded and are now in desperate financial straits.

In their judgement, the Appeals Court found that ACTMH had not breached their duty of care because Jonathan’s father, Keith, had told them his son would voluntarily admit himself to hospital on the day. The technicalities of this aspect are complex and arguable.

However, they also found that the AFP had no duty of care to Jonathan because of their duty to the general public to enforce the law. This is where the legal system and common sense part company.

It’s by no means the first time that we’ve confronted the problem of policemen using a deadly firearm against a mentally disturbed person wielding a stick or a knife.

We shouldn’t blame the policeman. People who have lost touch with reality are quite terrifying; they touch something in our innermost core that demands an instant response.

But we should blame the AFP for not having trained their officers to handle that response and for not providing them with an alternative means to subdue Jonathan Crowley. It is ridiculous – and reprehensible – that their options take a quantum leap from the relatively harmless capsicum spray to a deadly firearm. (And since the Taser seems to have problems of its own when used by police against the mentally ill, the electric shocker is clearly not the answer.)

The AFP – or the Attorney-General’s Department – should commission the CSIRO to come up with a range of options – from sticky nets designed to entangle the aggressors to chemical darts that put them instantly to sleep.

Are they really so thick that they haven’t thought of this already?

Meantime, the Crowleys have appealed to the High Court.

We must hope that our final arbiter is able to cut through the maze of legal sophistry to find a just outcome. But until then it really falls to the community – that’s us – to give them a helping hand to see them through.

Fortunately, we can do so quite simply through the Crowley Support Fund. Just contact the NAB.

Who Can You Trust?

In a world beleaguered by spin and confused messages, there's never been more need for diverse, trustworthy, independent journalism in Canberra.

Who can you trust? Well, for more than 25 years, "CityNews" has proudly been an independent, free, family-owned news magazine, serving the national capital with quality, integrity and authority. Through our weekly magazine and daily through our digital platforms, we constantly and reliably deliver high-quality and diverse opinion, news, arts, socials and lifestyle columns.

If you trust our work online and believe in the power of independent voices, I encourage you to make a small contribution.

Every dollar of support will be invested back into our journalism so we can continue to provide a valuably different view of what's happening around you and keep free.

Click here to make your donation and you will be supporting the future of journalism and media diversity in the ACT.

Thank you,

Ian Meikle, editor

Previous articleTemperature rises for cool fashion
Next article“Windows on Europe”- a perfect festival match
Robert Macklin
Journalist and author. Contact

Leave a Reply