Where was the leadership, Chief Minister? 

Share Canberra's trusted news:

“The Chief Minister has handed the poisoned chalice to Rachel Stephen-Smith. It would have been appropriate for Andrew Barr to show leadership and take responsibility for the Health portfolio himself,” writes JON STANHOPE

THE surprise resignation of Meegan Fitzharris as Minister for Health and Transport will leave a large hole in the ACT/Greens government.

Jon Stanhope
Jon Stanhope.

In my “CityNews” column of March 20 I said: “The management of ACT Health is looking increasingly problematic and the constantly negative press it is receiving is almost certainly now seriously damaging the reputation and standing of the Minister, Meegan Fitzharris.

“She is clearly the government’s best asset and most capable minister and frankly she should have been rotated out of Health before it got to the stage where the AMA is effectively demanding a Royal Commission into her management of the hospital.

“Chief Minister and Treasurer Andrew Barr… having taken the decision to effectively deny the hospital any growth funding thereby guaranteeing the stream of negative publicity that has eventuated, really should have stumped up and taken on the health portfolio himself rather than throw his best minister, and only credible alternative chief minister, to the sharks.”

There is nothing that I said in that column three months ago from which I resile. Ms Fitzharris has clearly been the standout member of the current government in terms of her work ethic, grasp of the detail of her portfolios, communication skills and her ability to connect with the community. She should be content with what she has achieved. 

Having said that, it is perhaps unfortunate that the extremely poor outcomes being achieved by our public hospitals will be an enduring part of Megan Fitzharris’ legacy. 

At one level that is fair and reasonable. She was the responsible Minister and a senior member of a Cabinet that deliberately chose to postpone the redevelopment of Canberra Hospital for a decade and slash the health budget to fund, in part, what she and her colleagues determined was a higher priority than health, namely the tram; the construction of which she oversaw. 

However the Chief Minister has now handed the poisoned chalice to Rachel Stephen-Smith. It would, as I have said previously, have been appropriate for Andrew Barr to show leadership and take responsibility for the Health portfolio himself.

Not only does he have a relatively light administrative workload as Chief Minister and Treasurer and should, in any event, be doing more of the heavy lifting but it would have shown that he was prepared to accept responsibility for the massive cuts that have been made to the health budget under his leadership and allowed him more scope to explain the cuts and accept responsibility for the impact they are having, particularly on low-income families without private health insurance.

The importance of Fitzharris to the government was emphasised following her resignation when the Chief Minister was moved to explain on ABC radio that had she not signalled her intention to resign that he may have done so himself. 

By this admission the Chief Minister faces the very real risk of being seen as a lame duck leader occupying his place in the government not out of conviction or dedication or because he has a plan or a passion for reform or because he wants to be there but out of a sense of duty based on the apparent belief that with Meegan’s departure there is no one else in the government with the capacity to fill his shoes. One does wonder what his deputy Yvette Berry thinks about that.

I do hope, nevertheless, that Rachel Stephen-Smith is prepared for the shock she will receive when she sits down with the director-general of ACT Health and receives the incoming minister’s briefing on the true state of the health budget. 

The implications for health care in the ACT of the continuing savage cuts being made to the budget of the Canberra and Calvary hospitals are deeply worrying. Just last week it was reported that there had been a further fall in the number of patients attending A&E and triaged as Category three (urgent) being seen in clinically approved times, from 37 per cent to 30 per cent. This is more than twice as bad, for example, as NSW.

Outcomes as poor as this are undoubtedly a reflection of the state of the health budget. What will be of particular concern to Ms Stephen-Smith as she absorbs the fact that the cuts to the health budget are unsustainable, is that the just released Budget and forecasts reveal that the health budget will be cut even more drastically over the next four years to levels that will not meet the increase in activity due to population growth and demographic change let alone increases in the cost of wages and medicine and new health technology.

Who Can You Trust?

In a world beleaguered by spin and confused messages, there's never been more need for diverse, trustworthy, independent journalism in Canberra.

Who can you trust? Well, for more than 25 years, "CityNews" has proudly been an independent, free, family-owned news magazine, serving the national capital with quality, integrity and authority. Through our weekly magazine and daily through our digital platforms, we constantly and reliably deliver high-quality and diverse opinion, news, arts, socials and lifestyle columns.

If you trust our work online and believe in the power of independent voices, I encourage you to make a small contribution.

Every dollar of support will be invested back into our journalism so we can continue to provide a valuably different view of what's happening around you and keep citynews.com.au free.

Click here to make your donation and you will be supporting the future of journalism and media diversity in the ACT.

Thank you,

Ian Meikle, editor

Previous articleLate-night servo robbed at knifepoint
Next articleLarge audience thrills to triumphant performance
Jon Stanhope
Jon Stanhope was Chief Minister from 2001 to 2011 and represented Ginninderra for the Labor Party from 1998. He is the only Chief Minister to have governed with a majority in the Assembly.


  1. Jon,

    Another brave and insightful article about the sad failings of our current Chief Minister.

    But Jon, what can be done to give us hope for the future? Like many Canberrans, I am depressed by the decline of our local Government since you helmed it and further despondent that rusted-on voters will most likely still vote Andrew Barr and Shane Rattenbury in again due to unhealthy habit and the social conservatism of the Liberals. Now, more than ever, we need hope. What is the mood within local Labor branches and the Right faction? Are they privately as sick of Barr as the rest of us? Are there the numbers to roll him internally? I fear that this is the only way out of this sad burlesque we are all despiritedly dancing to.

    Like many other commentators, I would love to see you back as Chief Minister. Someone with kindly ears for listening, a cool head for reason and a warm heart for the disadvantaged. Someone that we don’t have to watch and worry about or sigh into our coffee as we read the daily news. Someone who can move us past the current era of deviousness, developers and divas. Someone who can inspire trust that the ACT is competently doing its day job while also inspiring hope that the ACT really has a bright and inclusive future outside of the Chief Minister’s Newspeak brochures. Put simply, someone to cut the crap.

    Please consider taking up the mantle again. Your territory needs you now more than ever.


Leave a Reply