News location:

Canberra Today 6°/12° | Saturday, April 27, 2024 | Digital Edition | Crossword & Sudoku

How muddle-heads messed up a playground 

The new $7 million playground at Coombs… with many elements of the design and construction not disclosed, it’s more likely to have cost around $10 million. Photo: Paul Costigan

“On the weekend, immediate and nearby streets are packed with cars crammed into any available space… Then there’s the obvious question – where’s the toilets? There aren’t any,” writes PAUL COSTIGAN. Welcome to the new Coombs playground. 

THURSDAY, October 27 was the day that Deputy Chief Minister Yvette Berry officially opened the grand, designed playground in Coombs. 

Paul Costigan.

Ruth Park is named after the New Zealand-born, Australian author Rosina Ruth Lucia Park AM (1917-2010). There’s a sculpture of a muddle-headed wombat in the playground to celebrate one of her children’s books. 

She wrote tirelessly throughout her life, producing novels, children’s books, autobiographies and scripts for film and television.

This playspace will be listed for many awards and is already popular with families from across Canberra. The price has been declared to be around $7 million, although with many elements of the design and construction not disclosed, it is more likely around $10 million. 

With the other elaborately designed parks in nearby Whitlam and Denman Prospect, these new suburbs have the most expensive and super-designed playgrounds in Canberra.

This playground is popular. The complexity of the design and layout has encouraged a huge number of families to spend time there with children who are swamped with choice. On the weekend, the immediate and nearby streets are packed with cars crammed into any available space on the streets or illegally up on the verges and footpaths. 

In their wisdom, the government provided a few parking bays only, so narrow streets have become contested spaces and, at times, dangerous with kids running out to cross the street.

Then there’s the obvious question – where’s the toilets? There aren’t any. 

Parents are seen quietly walking with kids down the path towards the shrubbery. The issue of toilets for children and parents got scrambled thanks to the painful consultations and the weird decision-making processes involved with this park. 

For all sorts of logical reasons and according to good playground planning practices, this playground should have been constructed on a site much larger than this 0.9-hectare green space squeezed between a suburban street and a pond. 

Why this site? That answer would involve the long and tortuous explanation of the opaque workings of the former Land Development Authority and the now Suburban Land Agency. There were other options. 

The muddle-headed agency bureaucrats and their on-another-planet politicians had muddied the consultations so much that the nearby residents were forced to object to proposal after proposal that did not make sense. They were doing this while joining with others to advocate for community facilities and better playgrounds in the Molonglo area.

A monument to muddle-headed politicians and chief bureaucrats in the shape of that muddle-headed wombat? Photo: Paul Costigan

Residents who took up residencies nearby had done their research. The space beside the pond was originally designated as a thin linear green space with trees. Now, thanks to mentally confused politicians, it is a massive playspace that in a sensible world would have been built elsewhere – nearby. 

If it was on one of those more suitable larger sites, it would have had toilets and ample car bays. The nearby residents are now dreaming of what used to be quiet weekends.

The planning minister who changed the planning rules for Molonglo was Andrew Barr. According to his professional naivety, developers (not government) are to provide community facilities, shops and parks (with toilets). As a consequence of this neo-liberal, free-market approach to planning and the nature of his hollowed-out rules, the Molonglo developers were relaxed about selling houses on the promise that community stuff would come sometime in the future – maybe. 

On top of that, the present mess being made by the agencies involved in Canberra’s urban development, answer to Andrew Barr as Chief Minister and the grand poo-bah of ad hoc planning. This chief minister has continued to repeat the same planning blunders over and over again for more than a decade now – as if the results would one day be any different.

Ruth Park in Coombs is a great playspace. Just that it could have been so much better for everyone if someone intelligent had intervened and had a larger site selected. 

Interestingly, someone knew about these muddle-headed politicians and chief bureaucrats, and so a monument to them was positioned in the playspace in the shape of that muddle-headed wombat. People have been left to wonder which grand pooh-bah the sculpture represents.

Paul Costigan is a commentator on cultural and urban matters. There are more of his columns at citynews.com.au

 

Who can be trusted?

In a world of spin and confusion, there’s never been a more important time to support independent journalism in Canberra.

If you trust our work online and want to enforce the power of independent voices, I invite you to make a small contribution.

Every dollar of support is invested back into our journalism to help keep citynews.com.au strong and free.

Become a supporter

Thank you,

Ian Meikle, editor

Paul Costigan

Paul Costigan

Share this

11 Responses to How muddle-heads messed up a playground 

Carolyn says: 30 November 2022 at 8:58 am

Developers have always sold houses with promises of things to come. Regardless of whose in power. Indeed developers should be tightly regulated but neither the Liberals nor Labor would do that and I’m sure if a government ever did Mr. Costigan would be screaming ‘communism’.

Reply
Kim says: 2 December 2022 at 6:55 am

Coombs was developed by the Suburban Land Agency a government organisation and one that has made some of the worst decisions with no accountability.

Reply
Neil, of Queanbeyan says: 3 December 2022 at 4:08 pm

Carolyn, Mr Costigan is nearly always just screaming for common sense, as in this case (public toilets, sufficient parking). But, as usual, that is not what the wise people of Canberra want. That’s why they keep voting for these fools.

Reply
Jane says: 30 November 2022 at 10:28 am

Sadly, this sort of thing has become typical of the current ACT government. The longer they’ve been in power the worse they’ve become. As interesting as this new playground looks, with no toilets and little parking, think we’ll stick to the wonderful Arboretum playground, or one of the others that actually have facilities. It’s time for the ACT government to lift its game on this and many other issues.

Reply
Karena says: 30 November 2022 at 11:17 am

I’m a resident and each day there are loads of cars, trying to park close to the park as possible they are spreading to get the elusive car space & doing uturns in the narrow streets. We have been abused by people who when told it’s illegal to park on the nature strip or on the double white line and opposite the t intersection. We watch in horror as parents let their young children run across the road, unaided. We have rubbish in our street and nature strips even though there’s several rubbish bins.
We have been in contact with fix my street, to ask for some safety measures and no parking signs, many times only to be told there is no risk to anyone and the case is closed. Before the park was even in the planing stage people who parked illegally were booked, haven’t seen a ranger since the park opened. I’ve heard that people are even parking in residential car spaces. Car parking was never brought up in any of the consultations, we get abused on social media that we are the ones who didn’t want the car park.
The lights in the park are on 7 nights a week we were told that it’s a walking track and they are on for safety, well the lights are no where else? We not only have to endure the park during the day but at night young adult children drive to the park at all hours screaming and carrying on until they run out of alcohol and doing whatever.
If there is an emergency for a resident or someone at the park, the ambulance has no where to stop, this was ever thought of
It should not have been advertised as a destination park, when it’s in a high residential area.
Don’t get me wrong we wanted a park for our use as well and for our grandchildren, but certainly not at the magnitude it is.

Reply
inner Northian says: 30 November 2022 at 7:12 pm

The lack of toilets is an accessibility issue for adults too. Incontinence has many causes from MS through childbirth to simply old age. The decision not to include toilets will prevent many people from visiting.

Reply
S. Draw, K. Cab. says: 4 December 2022 at 2:54 pm

Toilets not in parks with kids playgrounds seems to be a Canberra thing. An example being Corroboree Park in Ainslie, where the local shrubbery are the urinals and fecal dumps. New suburbians will just have to make do and catch a tram to nowhere.

We raised this lack of toilets being an issue with families using Corroboree Park with ACT bureaucracy to be only told to politely get stuffed.

Maybe the relevant minister doesn’t have children and therefore cannot truly understand the import of such simple needs?

Foo Barr U.

Reply

Leave a Reply

Related Posts

Opinion

Why respect is a two-way street in law

Legal columnist HUGH SELBY offers a spirited response to an opinion column by Kelly Saunders in which she posed the question over a defendant's right to silence in a sexual assault prosecution. Selby argues she's wrong... 

Follow us on Instagram @canberracitynews