News location:

Friday, November 15, 2024 | Digital Edition | Crossword & Sudoku

Wrong-footed ‘Yes’ leadership sunk the Voice 

From left, Megan Davis…not a victim; Noel Pearson… wicked tongue; Marcia Langton…attracts enemies.

“The three elements of the campaign were in the wrong order – it should have been hearts first, heads second: that is, truth-telling that revealed the attempted colonial genocide – before the treaty, of which the Voice is part,” writes “The Gadfly” columnist ROBERT MACKLIN

The loss of the Voice referendum – now in serious prospect – is very sad, but not the existential tragedy that some well-meaning commentators of the left have labelled it.

It will not mean, for example, that Peter Dutton will be successful in importing the raging hatred from the hoi polloi that occurred in the UK Brexit disaster or the election of Donald Trump in the US. The genius of our electoral system with its compulsory voting will protect us from that particular horror story.

Instead, it is the conduct and the personnel of the “Yes” case that did us in. And it will be a spur to the eventual engagement of the Aboriginal people in the true essence of “closing the gap” – that is, their involvement at every level of government – and the negotiation of a treaty (or treaties) with the First Nations.

But it’s important to analyse the reasons for the failure before we can move forward with confidence; so in all humility, here’s my view after a dedication to the cause since I initiated Canberra’s “reconciliation march” across Canberra’s Commonwealth Bridge in 2000.

  1. From the beginning, the three elements of the campaign were in the wrong order – it should have been hearts first, heads second: that is, truth-telling that revealed the attempted colonial genocide, the massacres, the dispossession and virtual slavery – the secret history revealed – before the treaty, of which the Voice is part.
  2. The leaders were the wrong people – Noel Pearson is not a victim and he has a wicked tongue; Prof Marcia Langton is a leading academic who attracts enemies, but never wins them over. Megan Davis is not a victim, nor is she a persuasive performer in the media. Instead, Tom Calma presents the gentle face and friendly demeanor so necessary in such a debate… supported by the almost unlimited pleasant and articulate Aboriginal women we see daily on the ABC’s early evening program “The Drum”.
  3. They forgot the millions of migrants who have arrived in the last 30 years who knew nothing about Australian history – but could have been engaged through the “White Australia” story from the Chinese experience in the goldfields.
  4. The “Dark Emu” gibberish should have been exposed for what it is – not just contradicted in an academic tome or combined with Bill Gammage’s comparison of a European-stye parkland.
  5. PM Albanese’s soft “democratic” view re the “No” case. He’s tough enough with his only possible challenger, Tanya Plibersek, to destroy her credibility through the environment ministry permitting new coal mines; so why not tell Dutton et al to raise their own funding if they want to mount a “No” case.
  6. He could also warn the media against the false equivalence of the “Yes” and “No” cases. The Murdoch gang will do it anyway, but it truly is a false equivalence.
  7. Should the referendum be lost, the government should indicate that the work will continue – at a greater pace – through the parliament to “close the gap”. 
  8. They will work through states and will mandate Aboriginal participation at federal, state and council level; and immediately set a schedule to assist the Aboriginal people to begin a legal and UN case against the British government for reparations.

So, if Dutton thinks he has effectively ended Aboriginal advancement and participation in closing the gap by importing Trumpian politics, he’s not only just failed. By his foolish, racist politics, he has opened the way for the great attainment of making Australia whole… after 235 years of colonial occupation.

robert@robertmacklin.com  

Who can be trusted?

In a world of spin and confusion, there’s never been a more important time to support independent journalism in Canberra.

If you trust our work online and want to enforce the power of independent voices, I invite you to make a small contribution.

Every dollar of support is invested back into our journalism to help keep citynews.com.au strong and free.

Become a supporter

Thank you,

Ian Meikle, editor

Robert Macklin

Robert Macklin

Share this

2 Responses to Wrong-footed ‘Yes’ leadership sunk the Voice 

David says: 28 September 2023 at 9:20 am

Interesting article but suffering from the same problems as the Yes campaign in that it is ignoring the intelligence of Australian people. A quick fact check will show Dutton still lags Albo by a decent margin in preferred PM which means Australians, if they have a majority No vote, will not be doing so because “Dutton thinks he has effectively ended Aboriginal advancement and participation in closing the gap by importing Trumpian politics”. That is just a nonsense line as Australians are clearly being persuaded by other influences. Readers should read that line first before reading the rest of the article to put it in perspective. You might just find the majority of Australians want Australia to move forward as one with no racial divisional. Acknowledgement that closing the Gap is about ensuring everyone takes full advantage of colonization and this aim may not sit well with talk of reparations and treaties. No-one wants what Australia was before colonization or there would be no mention of closing the gap. If this referendum achieves anything it may be in the education of the wider public on all aspects of the debate which the Yes campaigners may need to carefully consider before writing articles like the one above.

Reply
Hamba says: 29 September 2023 at 4:25 pm

Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander people deserve far, far better than to be permanently represented by the hopeless, ‘progressive’ political class that has repeatedly failed them, as embodied in Davis, Pearson, and (former Communist League leader) Langton.

Reply

Leave a Reply

Related Posts

Follow us on Instagram @canberracitynews