News location:

Saturday, March 29, 2025 | Digital Edition | Crossword & Sudoku

Nuclear power plan could cause energy price blowout

The coalition’s nuclear plan could see electricity prices rise by hundreds of dollars, a report says (Jono Searle/AAP PHOTOS)

By Jacob Shteyman and William Ton in Canberra

Opposition Leader Peter Dutton continues to hold off on releasing costings for his nuclear power pitch, despite a report claiming household electricity bills will surge if the energy source is introduced to Australia.

The coalition’s plan to build seven nuclear reactors across five states on the sites of coal-fired power stations could cause consumers to pay hundreds of dollars a year more on electricity, research from the Institute for Energy Economics and Financial Analysis shows.

Typical household electricity bills could increase by $665 a year on average, while a family of four could face a $972 increase, according to the report released on Friday.

Energy Minister Chris Bowen has trashed Mr Dutton’s policy, calling on him to reveal his costings in a speech the opposition leader is set to deliver on Monday.

“The delay, costs, and paltry electric dividend shows me the coalition has learned little from the dysfunction of 10 years of stop-start energy policy driven by ideological culture wars instead of economics and engineering,” Mr Bowen said in an opinion piece in The Australian.

Mr Dutton questioned the report’s figures, accusing Mr Bowen of coming up with them.

“This is Chris Bowen, who promised before the election that power prices would come down by $275 – they’ve gone up by $1000,” he told Nine’s Today show on Friday.

“He’s predicting now that in 2037 your electricity bill will go up by $650. I mean, is that credible? Does anyone believe what Chris Bowen has to say? I suspect not.”

Adding baseload power to the electricity grid was essential as coal-fired power stations were removed from the system, Mr Dutton said.

Government minister Bill Shorten, who joined the opposition leader on the program, said Mr Dutton’s nuclear policy was “more lost than Burke and Wills” and told him to put his numbers out.

“We’ll give the costings in due course,” Mr Dutton said.

The report analysed six relevant nuclear projects in Europe and the US, including a cancelled US small modular reactor project, and found electricity bills increased by hundreds of dollars in every scenario.

It was unable to examine the experience of small modular reactors, the type proposed by the coalition, because no plants had been successfully completed in a democratic country.

Nuclear-generated electricity costs would likely be 1.5 to 3.8 times than current electricity generation in eastern Australia, with capital costs associated with construction reaching $90 billion based on international examples, report co-author Johanna Bowyer said.

“For nuclear power plants to be commercially viable without government subsidies and generating 24/7, electricity prices would need to rise to these higher levels to allow the nuclear power plants to recover their costs,” Ms Bowyer said.

“In a cost-of-living crisis, bill increases like this are a big deal.”

While costs associated with nuclear construction and financing don’t show up in the energy bills in nuclear nations, the report said that was because the plants were old and their costs had largely been paid off or governments had recouped costs through taxes separate from electricity prices.

Australia should instead persist with renewables accompanied by energy storage like batteries, which is the lowest-cost form of electricity supply available, said Con Hristodoulidis, a policy officer at the Clean Energy Council.

“Nuclear power is a high-cost, high-risk strategy for Australia,” he said.

Who can be trusted?

In a world of spin and confusion, there’s never been a more important time to support independent journalism in Canberra.

If you trust our work online and want to enforce the power of independent voices, I invite you to make a small contribution.

Every dollar of support is invested back into our journalism to help keep citynews.com.au strong and free.

Become a supporter

Thank you,

Ian Meikle, editor

Australian Associated Press

Australian Associated Press

Share this

3 Responses to Nuclear power plan could cause energy price blowout

David says: 21 September 2024 at 8:42 am

Didn’t ACT power bills go up by around $275 dollars recently (which some say is in response to the government $300 handout). If think it was reported in this publication from memory.

Any arguments about how much power prices will increase is silly as no-one involved has a leg to stand on as it’s going to go up whatever happens.

Also, remember, as the Clean Energy Council quote completely fails to do, the nuclear option is not about replacing any renewable energy solutions. It’s about guaranteed seasonal supply. i.e. what runs the hospitals when there isn’t enough stored renewable energy. Is this quoted knowing it is deliberately out of context and therefore false or is it quoted because the authors are too dumb to understand what they are writing about?

Also, we seem to have reached a saturation point in solar given this information (below) sent out to EnergyAustralia Customers with solar panels. The argument has never been about using renewables. It’s about storage and guaranteed supply.

Remember, gas as a back up is NOT a solution. We are trying to reduce green house gases. Gas burning produces carbon dioxide which is one of the three worst green house gases. Anyone who argues against nuclear should be asked when they plan to turn all fossil fuel based power generators off permanently.

From Energy Australia
“Solar Feed-in Tariff
Your solar flat feed-in tariff (FiT) will decrease from 1 October 2024.

What does this mean?
Your solar FiT is the price we pay you for any excess energy you produce with your rooftop solar system. This price is going down, which means you’ll get less money for selling your solar energy.

Why is my solar FiT decreasing?
As many households now have rooftop solar, there’s more solar generated energy going back into the grid. This has reduced the wholesale price of energy going back into the grid during the day when the sun is out. You can view the new FiT by clicking the ‘See your new rates’ button.”

Reply
Philip S says: 22 September 2024 at 11:24 am

This is a purely political issue. The question is: Does Australia want reliable 24/7 electricity supply at scale in an era of increasing power demand (think fast battery charging for vehicles and buses, electrified transport systems including fast rail, autonomous taxis, and the huge power demands of data centres and AI)? If so, nuclear power is the answer. If not, prepare for the brownouts and blackouts with petrol or diesel generators.

Reply

Leave a Reply

Follow us on Instagram @canberracitynews