News location:

Thursday, September 17, 2026 | Digital Edition | Crossword & Sudoku

Of genies, potatoes, principles and the opposition leader

Caricature: Paul Dorin

The Peter Principle asserts that a person continues to receive promotions up to that point where they reach a level of incompetence. Columnist HUGH SELBY cheekily urges Mr Dutton and his followers to reflect on this. 

Crime, crime and more crime, from one end of Canberra to the other, that’s what my news feed was giving me on Sunday, the day intended by the Maker to be a day of rest, contemplation and tranquillity.

Hugh Selby.

You’ll appreciate that something diverting is needed to push aside that relentless negativity. 

Even if I was religiously observant it was too late for morning service and evensong was too far away. In the early afternoon the escape might be watching the cricket (or rewatching amazing catches in Sri Lanka), going to the pool, or going out into the garden to clean up the never-ending deluge of falling leaves and bark from large, inappropriate, ACT government street trees.

The government-supplied green waste bin full to overflowing, another bin full still on the ground, gritted teeth, go back inside away from the noisy thunder (clearly warnings from Him) and search the internet for calming therapy.

Thanks be! There’s an online Therapy Store that sells the answer to my angst: they have a “slimmer, more active Mr Potato Head that has more holes than he used to and more facial features! You will love putting his nose where his ear should be and building many different versions of the original potato friend”.

From time to time, fate or artistry play cruel tricks, such as the oil painting of the horse rider and the horse with similar face features, or the multi-coloured figurines made by English potters of ugly, vicious dogs whose stocky, gnarled, whip-holding masters looked much the same as the dogs.

These wall and mantlepiece tricks do not explain how our wanna be prime minister has been saddled with the Mr Potato Head moniker. Even The Australian joined in the fun some months back, a move that suggested the label could be positive, not wholly negative.

That’s a thought that runs counter to “putting his nose where his ear should be”. Or does it? He had his ear to the ground and his nose to the wind, and his nose to the ground and his ear to the dog-whistling perennials of crime and immigration, in his recent besting of Albo on the mandatory minimum terms for certain hate conduct. 

He so terrified dear Albo that Labor didn’t even put a sunset clause into those provisions – an obvious approach for anyone who wasn’t running around terrified. 

But positive or negative, I don’t want the international media later this year reporting our national politics, or our relationships with the Emperor Donnie and other international figures, under the headline, “Aussie Potato Head says”. It’s not a good look is it? Not for him, and not for the potato.

What’s not to like about potatoes? They have a range and adaptability far beyond that of our career politicians. Potatoes can be washed, then peeled or not, before being boiled, mashed with mayo and parsley and chives, roasted or air fried with bacon bits and sour cream, hashbrowned, served as potato scallops, and – let’s leave the best to last – chips. Chips thick, thin, long or stubby, salted, chicken salted, tomato sauce, spicy sauce, whatever sauce takes your fancy.

Contrary to common error the potato did not originate in Ireland or in Europe. The Spaniards found it among the Inca Indians who had used the time it took to cook a potato as a measurement of time. Strangely it took many decades before Europeans recognised its value. Meantime, it was “out of place”.

Peter excelled as the minister for dealing nastily with “would-be” refugees. His public persona has never had any time for these “out of placers”. Not even potato time. From 2014 to 2021 his portfolios covered Immigration, Border Protection and Home Affairs. Then he briefly had Defence.

The Potato Head moniker is inapt, even inept. A much better image is that of Aladdin’s magic vessel, that lamp – the one that when rubbed releases the genie who grants wishes. Visualise Peter’s head as that shining, metallic work of art and the light it brings to the lives of those around it (Please put aside his lack of understanding about the complexities of the middle east.).

To date, the rubbing has always been to the right. That explains his politics. If only it was rubbed the other way, then the endearing, compassionate man could be on display.

Those who mock this theory should remember Malcolm Fraser, he who bested our Gough. Post his time as Prime Minister, Malcolm’s life was filled with good works, so much so that his likeness to an Easter Island statue was an endearment. 

In 1969 (the year before Peter’s birth), a timeless analysis was published, setting out the Peter Principle. This asserts that a person continues to receive promotions up to that point where they reach a level of incompetence.

I urge our wanna be prime minister, one time Minister for Bullying and War Toys, and his supporters, to reflect on this principle. There is a light in his magic vessel but ’tis but a flicker, not a shining beacon of hope.

 

News all day, every day at CityNews.com.au.

Who can be trusted?

In a world of spin and confusion, there’s never been a more important time to support independent journalism in Canberra.

If you trust our work online and want to enforce the power of independent voices, I invite you to make a small contribution.

Every dollar of support is invested back into our journalism to help keep citynews.com.au strong and free.

Become a supporter

Thank you,

Ian Meikle, editor

Hugh Selby

Hugh Selby

Share this

3 Responses to Of genies, potatoes, principles and the opposition leader

David says: 10 February 2025 at 2:56 pm

Hmm, I think the Peter Principle is more in play on the other side of politics given the state we are now in and knowing the present government, who arrived in office on the reset after Covid, had many chances to change the path we are taking. For instance, they knew the cost of building houses had significantly increased so increasing the demand on housing was always going to be problematic. Especially for those the government choose to bare the brunt of the crisis, average income earners looking to enter the property market as owner occupiers. Given the opportunity they had the state of the current housing crisis arguably lies at their feet. As many have quoted, it’s probably the worst crisis we’ve had which means Dutton could do anything and still look good. Well, let’s reconsider that, maybe the worst thing they have done is perform so badly Dutton could do anything and still look good.

As for the childish play on immigration and the English, maybe you should chat to the English about the challenges they are having with immigration before you put too much salt on your hot chips.

Do you honestly believe the players in the current government should be given a second chance? Especially as they are likely to take any victory as confirmation they are doing the right thing. If they were able to look around and go, yikes, what a mess, then maybe given them a second chance. However, they seem intent on trying to polish things just not meant to be polished.

Reply
cbrapsycho says: 10 February 2025 at 4:59 pm

Whilst having to agree with some of David’s comments, such as that the current government have had plenty of time to change course, it is ridiculous to lay the current housing crisis ‘at their feet’ given it has been many decades in the making, most of that time under a coalition government. The current housing crisis did not begin 3 years ago!

As for the level of competence, it is clear that both Dutton & Albanese are beyond their levels of competence. Their followers are equally responsible for not ousting them to put better leaders of our country in place, assuming they’re there, willing and available.

It is currently extremely clear that independent members of parliament are way more capable than those leading the major parties and even the minor parties. We need more like Helen Haines, David Pocock, Andrew Wilkie and even those with unusual views like Jacqui Lambie who actually do represent their communities rather than their personal careers via a political party.

These independents are the people who raise the issues that the majors work to hide under the guise of bipartisanship, the issues that much of the media ignore and the public doesn’t get to hear about or discuss before new legislation is put in place, legislation that often has harmful consequences for some groups. We need people representing us with the guts to speak up and the willingness to risk to risk their jobs to do what’s right.

We don’t need QLD police who continue to police the public through all of their portfolios as Dutton has, and who do it badly with bias. Neither do we need people who go quiet, who drop their espoused values to support the wealthy and powerful, as they are not leaders. Where are they????

Reply
David says: 10 February 2025 at 7:40 pm

Do not get lost in the argument of, “we were already heading for the ice field so it’s not our fault we turned into the middle of it”. Leadership is about taking the reigns and steering the best course. The current government could have easily steered a course to start steering us away from the ice field of the housing crisis yet they choose to make it worse. Had they chosen a course to steer us away it would be very unfair to blame them for the crisis but by making it worse they have to take the responsibility for the crisis. Otherwise we can never expect a government to fix anything because they can always argue, “well it was there before we started so it’s now our fault, even though we’ve made it worse”. Simple rule, you willingly make it worse then you take them blame. It is very clear that it has got significantly worse in the last 3 years. Exclaiming that is was only 3 years actually makes the government look worse.

I would love to vote for the independents. If I could I would reincarnate Don Chip. The trouble is, what do they now stand for other than a bunch of people mostly focused on fighting their own local battles. Have you ever wandered into a pub and asked people what they think the Teals stand for? What the the Teals announce in their last news conference? Many Australians still remember the sad demise of the Democrats and have experienced a constant background of independents at war with each other, failing into and out of alliances. What we need is a cohesive leadership within that group, yet, they are all too busy being independent to realise they are just misspelling irrelevant. If you don’t want to blame the government for the terrible decisions they made drastically increasing the demand for housing, well beyond the rate of supply, and refusing to act to free up the many many vacant houses already built, then perhaps look at who had the balance of power in the senate.

Sometimes you have to be most critical of the people you want to support otherwise you and they will blindly go down a path to failure.

Reply

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

*

*

Related Posts

Opinion

KEEPING UP THE ACT

There's an art to breaking election promises. KEEPING UP THE ACT thinks Minister Chris Steel has all the moves.

Opinion

Sex claims: what’s the need to name schools?

"Even given the worst possible outcomes for the accused, what possible significance could their schools be in investigations to allegations of events in a suburban alley and a private home," asks former school principal NOEL BEDDOE.

Follow us on Instagram @canberracitynews