Review / Unconvincing note in ‘Bronze’ concert

Artistic director Geoff Grey, photo Peter Hislop
CANBERRA Wind Symphony’s “Bronze” concert at The Q began on an unconvincing note. Artistic director Geoff Grey explained to the audience that printed programs were not provided and could, after all, be accessed by a mobile phone from the webpage. This, he explained, was quite deliberate – a measure to save trees and bring the audience into the digital age. Had the subsequent concert been a triumph, this minor annoyance may have been forgotten.

It was not a triumph.

The lack of printed program necessitated an almost constant commentary from the conductor. There were mother-in-law jokes. There was, quite literally, a plastic rose between-the-teeth moment.

As something billed as “new music”, it is difficult to imagine a weaker program than Canberra Wind Symphony’s “Bronze”. All of the works chosen by Grey, with the exception of the Rimsky-Korsakov, struggled to assert any resemblance to new music – and Rimsky Korsakov completed his work in 1900. The program began with Samuel Hazo’s “Ride” from 2004, a simplistic work displaying the influence of American band music. This minor work could, with hindsight, be considered the strongest contemporary inclusion of “Bronze”.

Martyn Hancock’s 2018 work “Aurora Australis” is admirable as an exercise in orchestration. It showcased the considerable talents of Canberra Wind Symphony’s young players. The work opens on a tierce de Picardie cadence, a popular film music trope denoting sunburst– a trope repeated so often by Hancock that its effect had migrated from mildly effective to mildly annoying. “Aurora Australis” was a chimera of populist film music devices, employing harmonic language lifted from Stravinsky. Toward the end of this work a single moment of authenticity shone out – a few bars of senza vibrato flute doubled with pitched percussion and synthesiser – I wondered what an entire work written in this voice might have yielded.

Billed as “new music”, David Maslanka’s “Liberation” from 2010, featured large sections of Gregorian chant in Latin – a kind of Monty Pythonesque parody of monophony that made me long for the relative aural modernity of actual Gregorian chant. “Liberation” seems to be essentially a medley of film scenes stitched together. There is a Kung Fu Tam-Tam, a few seconds of cowboy music, some Indiana Jones. An endless array of perfect and plagal cadences. Canberra Wind Symphony performed this work with musicality and ease. The saxophonist, in particular, was impressive – and I would tell you his name, had there been a program.

In what was surely the highlight of the evening, principal flautist Sarah Nielson gave a beautiful performance of Nicolai Rimsky-Korsakov’s “Flight of the Bumblebee”, a work prefaced by the conductor appearing with a plastic rose gripped between his teeth and what was probably supposed to be a cabaret shimmy. Nielson’s Rimsky-Korsakov was accomplished by anyone’s standards. She exhibited a warm tonal range, impeccable intonation, and flowing sculpted phrases. It was announced that Nielson had won a prestigious scholarship.

“Bronze” came to pedestrian conclusion with two works by Eric Whitacre, his 2005 “Lux Aurumque” and his 1993 “Ghost Train”. This latter was a programmatic work featuring mimetic train whistles and choo choo noises. In fact, the only unifying element of this work was the rondo-like return to train sounds. It would take more space than is afforded here to list the early 20th century works that appear in “Ghost Train” in what might be generously be described as ‘quotation’. Stravinsky is quoted the most often – “A Soldier’s Tale”, “Firebird”, and “The Rite of Spring”. Steve Reich’s “Different Trains” also has a cameo appearance.

Grey’s overarching message was one of supporting new music, and for this he should be applauded. But “Bronze” was not a concert of new music. It was a concert of marginally popular film music – the musical equivalent of a neighbourhood painting fair in park. It is an enormous shame for the talented players of Canberra Wind Symphony.


Who Can You Trust?

In a world beleaguered by spin and confused messages, there's never been more need for diverse, trustworthy, independent journalism in Canberra.

Who can you trust? Well, for more than 25 years, "CityNews" has proudly been an independent, free, family-owned news magazine, serving the national capital with quality, integrity and authority. Through our weekly magazine and daily through our digital platforms, we constantly and reliably deliver high-quality and diverse opinion, news, arts, socials and lifestyle columns.

If you trust our work online and believe in the power of independent voices, I encourage you to make a small contribution.

Every dollar of support will be invested back into our journalism so we can continue to provide a valuably different view of what's happening around you and keep free.

Click here to make your donation and you will be supporting the future of journalism and media diversity in the ACT.

Thank you,

Ian Meikle, editor

Previous articleArts / Schools Reconciliation Challenge launched
Next articleReview / Rapturous concert of Spanish music


  1. In contrast with the review, I thought the concert was excellent! Having been to a number of the CWS concerts in recent years, I appreciate the commentary by Geoff and his introductions. The reviewer seems to also have a particular dislike for what she terms, ‘film music’. While she is naturally entitled to her view, incorporating her own tastes so strongly, as opposed to reviewing the performance on its own merits, seems a tad trite to say the least.

    Nonetheless, congrats again to the CWS for what I though was an excellent effort and hopefully many more to come.

Leave a Reply