News location:

Canberra Today 6°/9° | Friday, April 26, 2024 | Digital Edition | Crossword & Sudoku

Greens need to get real on biodiversity and stop the spin

“Canberra Matters” columnist PAUL COSTIGAN urges the ACT Greens to stop spinning and get out and do something real to fix the urban habitats and urban forest.

WHEN “CityNews” agreed to a reply from the ACT Greens to last week’s “Canberra Matters” column arguing how the Greens have failed to protect the territory’s biodiversity, I sensed something in their piece had been overlooked, perhaps it was misleading even.

Paul Costigan.

Their response reads like a media release written by a communications adviser with the usual spin of how wonderful the world is thanks to the ACT Greens. It is worth a read.

There is so much that could be said about their blast of self-congratulation. However, the focus should remain on biodiversity and the work to deal with climate change. And let’s not forget the call to urgent action published in the IPCC’s mid-year report – something the ACT Greens did not mention.

A reminder, despite what was said in their statement, biodiversity was mentioned once in their agreement with Labor. Another reminder is that former Greens MLA, Caroline Le Couteur, published figures that urban trees were declining by 3000 a year, that at least 40,000 new trees or more were needed to catch up, and the minimum needed now was at least 7000 a year. The biodiversity and greenery of established areas continues to be eroded through inappropriate – but ACT government approved – redevelopments.

So when we get to drive down Northbourne Avenue again, when we see what happened to West Basin, are shocked by the town cramming in the Woden Town centre and the absence of adequate greenery in Molonglo – will we feel better because of all those worthy words as published this week from the ACT Greens?

The ACT Greens need to take a look outside and observe the realities of how much of the urban habitats and urban forest are being degraded and to acknowledge that this has been the outcome of their partnership with ACT Labor to form government. And then do something real and stop getting communications advisers to publish more words.

Another four weeks…”How could the Chief Minister ask me to continue to eat croissants in my garden instead of exercising my right to sit around in cafes talking to people?” Costigan jokes.

THEN there was the announcement that, when it comes to the pandemic in Canberra, things are not good and it was necessary to extend the lockdown. That is, people were being directed to stay home as much as possible for

My silly reaction about croissants is far more serious than the naff stuff produced by the Canberra Liberals. They published their usual media statements this week demanding that the government provide a pathway out of the pandemic and for more certainty for how and when the lockdown and other restrictions will end. Best of luck with that. 

Surely someone in the Canberra Liberals office has been watching the news and has realised that this stuff is going to continue for quite a while yet. Certainty is a fantasy given how every country is continually changing their plans in dealing with the constantly changing circumstances of this pandemic.

Instead of acting as if they are still the prisoner of Senator Zed Seselja and his fringe thinking, the Canberra Liberals would be far better putting together positive messages of support for already stressed Canberra communities. 

Politicians who want to be taken seriously need to counter the misinformation being put about, and to encourage people to log on to the ACT’s covid website to get their information first hand – not translated by someone else.

A SHOUT out to the Chief Minister and the chief health officer, Dr Kerryn Coleman. The month extension was a tough call, but the right call given what is still happening and that some people still do not get it. 

I think Dr Coleman was spot on when she said (I paraphrase) she didn’t want to raise false hope for Canberrans. She didn’t want people to be working towards something that authorities weren’t very sure about right now. 

I am not convinced the daily fronting up to the cameras is necessary. Please, Chief Minister, take a day or two off. There must be a few other things sitting on your desk requiring attention.

Who can be trusted?

In a world of spin and confusion, there’s never been a more important time to support independent journalism in Canberra.

If you trust our work online and want to enforce the power of independent voices, I invite you to make a small contribution.

Every dollar of support is invested back into our journalism to help keep citynews.com.au strong and free.

Become a supporter

Thank you,

Ian Meikle, editor

Paul Costigan

Paul Costigan

Share this

3 Responses to Greens need to get real on biodiversity and stop the spin

Jane says: 18 September 2021 at 11:31 am

That’s what my husband and I thought too, when we read the Greens response to you, Paul. It read like a pre-election puff piece. It certainly didn’t answer anything you raised in your article. As you said, they need to step outside their offices and, dare I say, out of their own suburbs for a while and open their eyes. They lost a lot of their integrity when they lost Caroline as an MLA. The only saving grace is that most of this new crop of ACT Greens MLAs are “one term wonders”.
I agree with what you said in the rest of this piece too. If more people read and followed the ACT Health Covid information website instead of others’ précis of what they think is going on and social media, they’d be a lot better informed. We’re also over the daily press conferences, where the same questions are asked and answered over and over again. Surely a simple media release would suffice most days.

Reply
Martin says: 19 September 2021 at 1:00 am

Jane: You have two comment I will comment upon: (1) “The only saving grace is that most of this new crop of ACT Greens MLAs are “one term wonders”.” Really? Will that not be determined by the electorate come the next ACT election? (2) “We’re also over the daily press conferences, where the same questions are asked and answered over and over again”. Have you considered simply not watching the conferences? I don’t watch them daily. But that the Chief Minister still makes the time to appears daily is at least some acknowledgement of the impact of COVID, should it spiral, let alone the economic / social impact the restrictions are already having on many Canberrans.

Reply
Jane says: 19 September 2021 at 2:46 pm

Martin:
(1) Yes, of course it will, as it always is, and always has been. When we saw and heard what so many of the new crop of Greens had to say about what they were going to do if elected, we had high hopes. Sadly the reality is very different.
(2) Who said we watch every day, or even that we watch the whole thing when we do? I merely made the observation that it seems a waste of time for so many to be there each day asking and answering the same questions on rotation. One only has to read the reports each day to see that, no need to watch them to know that.
(3) It was good to see that Andrew had a day off today. It’s about time, as he deserves it.
Stay well Martin.

Reply

Leave a Reply

Related Posts

Opinion

Why respect is a two-way street in law

Legal columnist HUGH SELBY offers a spirited response to an opinion column by Kelly Saunders in which she posed the question over a defendant's right to silence in a sexual assault prosecution. Selby argues she's wrong... 

Follow us on Instagram @canberracitynews