News location:

Canberra Today 2°/5° | Friday, April 26, 2024 | Digital Edition | Crossword & Sudoku

Stone the crows… shoot, gas them, I don’t care

The Torresian crow… far more vicious than the sprightly myna.

“Crows actively kill the beautiful little finches, wrens and any other they can bully and destroy. No wonder they hide and stay quiet,” writes an animated ROBERT MACKLIN.

WERE I religious, I’d say they were Scott Morrison’s “evil ones” incarnate. We don’t call their gathering a “murder of crows” for nothing. 

Robert Macklin.

The time has come to fight back against these killers of the birds whose songs used to bring such joy to the national capital. 

Stone them, as the old Aussie exclamation would have it or shoot them, trap them or gas them, I really don’t care, just as long as we do what we did with those invading Indian mynas in the 1990s – eliminate the vile predators and stop them despoiling our city with their snarling, mournful, cries.

Like the myna, the crow is an invader, from Papua down through the Torres Strait. It’s known to science as the Torresian crow, but it’s far more vicious than the sprightly myna.

I’ve hated them since my jackarooing days in western Queensland. During a drought they gathered round sheep stuck in the boggy mud of a dam and pecked their eyes out while they lived. They did the same to the manager’s dear old horse, Belle, a retired veteran of 26 years who got bogged in a gully in one of the holding paddocks. She was still alive when we found her. We put her down to end her pain. It broke the boss’ heart. 

My mate Neil had a good idea. He set up a trap near the gallows where each afternoon during shearing we killed an old wether for the shearers’ cook. He put some guts under a box he’d elevated with a stick; and when a crow finally went for the guts, he pulled the string holding the stick and trapped it.

Then he got some whitewash and I helped him paint the crow with it. When we let it go it flew towards its gang – the “murder” – and off they flew like bats out of hell, screaming at this white apparition heading their way.

We cheered it on!

Years later I found myself producing documentary films for the Asian Development Bank. Every six months I’d make a new doco about a group of countries that were building up their economies with big cheap loans from the ADB. 

One year the countries were Sri Lanka, India, Nepal, Pakistan and Bangladesh in that order. And from the moment we arrived in Colombo we were surrounded by the harsh and horrible cawing of crows until many weeks later we finally departed Dhaka. For all that time I couldn’t get old Belle out of my mind.

Then in the 1990s when the myna invasion was destroying the native birdlife I became a supporter of CSIRO scientist Dr Chris Tidemann who not only campaigned against them but invented a painless trap to capture and kill hundreds of them. The mynas just forced the others out with their aggression. The crows actively kill the beautiful little finches, wrens and any other they can bully and destroy. No wonder they hide and stay quiet.

Today, the crows’ monotonous caws are the first thing we hear each morning and the last call of the afternoon. The neighbourhood is bereft of that glorious dawn chorus that greets the morn when we take a break at our Tuross bolthole. 

But then last week at the coast, just as it reached its orchestral peak, suddenly came that single, snarling, mournful cry. The Murderers had found Arcadia.

It was a call to arms.

We either fight back or surrender our native birdlife to their grisly fate.

Dr Tidemann, sir, we need you now.

robert@robertmacklin.com 

 

Who can be trusted?

In a world of spin and confusion, there’s never been a more important time to support independent journalism in Canberra.

If you trust our work online and want to enforce the power of independent voices, I invite you to make a small contribution.

Every dollar of support is invested back into our journalism to help keep citynews.com.au strong and free.

Become a supporter

Thank you,

Ian Meikle, editor

Robert Macklin

Robert Macklin

Share this

2 Responses to Stone the crows… shoot, gas them, I don’t care

Claudia says: 17 June 2021 at 7:29 pm

Hi Robert,

I understand this is an opinion article, but it comes across as quite confused and misleading.

Firstly, Torresian Crows are native to both Australia and Papua New Guinea. They natively occur in Qld, NT, and WA. Although I have heard of them expanding southwards, they are not generally considered invasive (unlike the common mynah, which was deliberately introduced by humans in a miscalculated attempt to reduce grapevine pests).

The Torresian Crow is also very uncommon in Canberra. The main corvids we have here are Australian Ravens, and more rarely, Little Ravens. These are both also native species. Although it was probably Torresian Crows that you had such a bad experience with in w. Qld, the article implies that they are also here in Canberra.

I sympathise with the unsettling experiences you had with the crows while jackarooing, however I think it is damaging to try and assign morals to wild animals. Conversely, I could claim the Torresian crows are gallant heroes of northern Australia, as they have figured out how to eat the cane toads without getting poisoned. But I realise they are just hungry and clever 🙂 Even with the common mynah, it not helpful to hate the species. We understand our responsibility to remove a species that is damaging from the environment, but should endeavour to do so in a way that is humane and reduces cruelty to individual birds.

I don’t think the situation with Torresian crows is comparable to the issue with common mynah, and I don’t see how this article is relevant to Canberra. I am somewhat concerned that your call to arms will result in cruelty against all manner of corvids. The species are difficult to tell apart. All three species I have mentioned here are native, and subsequently protected.

There is even solid emerging evidence that corvids evolved in Australia. There is a great (similarly named) article in The Conversation on this topic: https://theconversation.com/stone-the-crows-could-corvids-be-australias-smartest-export-4346

The Crows have always been in Arcadia.

Reply

Leave a Reply

Related Posts

Opinion

Why respect is a two-way street in law

Legal columnist HUGH SELBY offers a spirited response to an opinion column by Kelly Saunders in which she posed the question over a defendant's right to silence in a sexual assault prosecution. Selby argues she's wrong... 

Follow us on Instagram @canberracitynews