News location:

Canberra Today 8°/10° | Monday, July 4, 2022 | Digital Edition | Crossword & Sudoku

Deaf Greens do nothing as trees come down

And the trees go where? Canberra suburbs not designed for climate change.

“The community sector is expected to remain polite about criticising the planning bureaucrats. The community is expected to remain polite as the trees come down and the suburban biodiversity disappears!” writes “Canberra Matters” columnist PAUL COSTIGAN

THE worst behaviour of any politician or bureaucrat is when a mistake has been brought to their attention, that they double down, pretend there’s nothing wrong, produce alternative facts and discredit those who have identified the error.

Paul Costigan.

The North Canberra Community Council (NCCC) meeting on May 15 discussed in fine detail how, in late April and early May, something went wrong with changes being made to the 2019 Draft Variation 369. 

This was the initiative regularly boasted about by the ACT Greens as a step towards enhancing the suburban greenery and increasing permeable surfaces. Unfortunately for the trees, after 30 months it is still a draft with no action taken.

No-one was sure whether this mysterious change was a mistake or something quietly introduced to make the 2019 variations ineffectual. The work on these changes by a couple of residents has been forensic. The view was that the alterations introduced made the planning variation hard to understand and possibly allowed for loopholes to be exploited. Instead of protecting the environment and dealing with climate, the new version would allow suburban greenery to be reduced even more. 

Three ACT Greens government politicians were online for the NCCC meeting and witnessed the evidence highlighting the questionable changes being introduced. They were Jo Clay, Rebecca Vassarotti and Shane Rattenbury. 

Despite being the ACT Minister for the Environment (trees and greenery and biodiversity), Ms Vassarotti made it clear that it was not her portfolio responsibility. 

She also said that the new variations were introduced because people had bought land for houses and they should not be disadvantaged by new legislation. This spin was quickly put in its place when someone reminded the meeting that the norm is for such legislative changes to not apply to those already with development applications underway.

The three ACT Greens politicians sort of indicated that they sort of saw what the problem was and sort of committed to get people together to talk this through. That did not happen.

On June 1, in the Assembly, the ACT Greens member for Ginninderra, Jo Clay, asked a “Dorothy Dixer” (a planted question) of her government colleague, Planning Minister Mick Gentleman.

Statements were made by the minister, unchallenged by the ACT Greens or Canberra Liberals, that the variations on variations were temporary and would be fixed later with the next stages of the planning reforms – maybe in 2023. 

This was news to those outside the Assembly’s and the bureaucracy’s rarified worlds. Translated: People had to accept that they were wrong about the mess being made to the original intent of the variation; they were misguided even though they spent hours unpacking the wording in the new variation legislation. The message was that community councils should realise that there was nothing amiss with a 30-month-old draft variation being varied again, that these were temporary variations added to take it through to later this year, and then it will be varied again sometime in 2023. And the trees, the greenery and the biodiversity? Don’t you worry about that!

This was a clear case of “gaslighting” the community. The ACT Greens’ Dorothy Dixer can only be seen as an action to create a false narrative in the hope that others would question the residents’ judgement and motives. 

This despite the fact that three ACT Greens had seen the hard evidence that someone in the planning bureaucracy had made a mistake – or had done something deliberately. And yet again, the Canberra Liberals remain silent on this planning mess.

As no-one dreams that the politicians write legislation, the chaos must have been created in the planning directorate. The ACT Greens and ACT Labor politicians take their lead on planning matters from the directorate’s bureaucrats. 

Yet, the community sector is expected to remain polite about criticising the planning bureaucrats. The community is expected to remain polite as the trees come down and the suburban biodiversity disappears! 

When the planning bureaucrats behave badly and display incompetence, do residents require permission from politicians to criticise this government’s unelected planning chief? Is the climate expected to also be as patient and as polite as the community sector?

Paul Costigan is a commentator on cultural and urban matters. There are more of his columns at


Who can be trusted?

In a world of spin and confusion, there’s never been a more important time to support independent journalism in Canberra.

If you trust our work online and want to enforce the power of independent voices, I invite you to make a small contribution.

Every dollar of support is invested back into our journalism to help keep strong and free.

Become a supporter

Thank you,

Ian Meikle, editor

Paul Costigan

Paul Costigan

Share this

One Response to Deaf Greens do nothing as trees come down

Palmerston's Lament says: June 23, 2022 at 12:10 pm

I think, it is fair to say, that I approach the annual feasting of the Rates increases with much the same joy and excitement. The spin will be “you are richer than you think so deal with it” but the foundational reality is one of broken promises by the Treasurer (what is his name again?) and redirection, always and guaranteed redirection, by the Chief Minister (name escapes me here).

I suggest too that any semblance of a progressive and humanitarian budget, whenever that gets handed down, will reflect more trickle down economic platitudes and failed neo-con and Thatcherite economic models that we know now do not work and are just band aid covers for hiding systemic failure.

The Greens, the so called moderating force in this bizarre triangle, have failed to live up to any expectation of control. They are as addicted to the sugar hits of power that drip from the CM’s largesse. And they will do nothing for their electorates at Budget time beyond enabling the CM’s personal, but very out of key, song of brilliance.

The Liberals and other rightist groups have no hope, and will play no part in change, as they are as irrelevant as the Greens. Rates, fees and charges will got up, trees will come down and the same discussions will be had ad nauseum.


Leave a Reply

Related Posts


Democracy muted as Mick calls in YWCA project

"Given the Christian values, the founders must be turning in the graves at the YWCA's actions to be horrible towards residents along with challenging the democratic processes in how planning decisions should be made," writes PAUL COSTIGAN.

Follow us on Instagram @canberracitynews