News location:

Canberra Today 5°/8° | Monday, June 3, 2024 | Digital Edition | Crossword & Sudoku

Trans woman’s case raises ‘constitutional matters’

By JACK GRAMENZ in Sydney

A WOMAN’S lawsuit against an online platform where she was blocked after being “considered male” could raise constitutional matters, a court has heard.

Roxanne Tickle is suing social media platform Giggle for Girls, an app “made for women by women” that uses artificial intelligence to detect a user’s gender.

After initial approval to access the platform in February 2021, Ms Tickle says it was revoked by September.

“I believe that I am being discriminated against by being provided with extremely limited functionality of a smartphone app by the app provider compared to that of other users because I am a transgender woman,” Ms Tickle wrote in a complaint with the Australian Human Rights Commission filed in December 2021.

“I am legally permitted to identify as female.”

Giggle responded Ms Tickle had been removed because she had been “considered male” by her appearance in a selfie she uploaded.

Giggle and its CEO Sally Grover did not know Ms Tickle was transgender and it did not inform the decision to revoke her access, lawyers wrote in response to the complaint in March last year.

Ms Grover described Ms Tickle as a “trans identified male” in a social media post less than three weeks later, alleging Ms Tickle wanted her to be “re-educated”.

Ms Tickle sued Giggle and Ms Grover in the Federal Circuit and Family Court in July last year, dropping actions due to concerns over growing legal costs.

In a new lawsuit filed in December, Ms Tickle seeks damages, a written apology, and restored access to the platform.

“This is the sort of case, without going into the ins and outs of it, where there are likely to be… strongly held opposing views,” Federal Court Justice Robert Bromwich said at a case management hearing on Friday.

Ms Tickle is requesting the court place a “cost capping order” to limit the amount of money recoverable by whoever is successful in the lawsuit.

Giggle’s barrister Bridie Nolan said the cost-capping application needs to be formally moved and proved.

“(The respondent) plans to raise constitutional matters, which will definitely influence the court’s approach to any cost capping,” Ms Nolan said on Friday.

The attorney-general will be notified and may also wish to be heard on constitutional matters, Ms Nolan said.

Giggle has also given notice it will object to the competency of the application, while Ms Tickle will seek an extension of time.

Justice Bromwich will consider both at a hearing on April 28, however he told lawyers for the two parties they should be able to find some agreement on whether the matter can proceed before then.

Who can be trusted?

In a world of spin and confusion, there’s never been a more important time to support independent journalism in Canberra.

If you trust our work online and want to enforce the power of independent voices, I invite you to make a small contribution.

Every dollar of support is invested back into our journalism to help keep citynews.com.au strong and free.

Become a supporter

Thank you,

Ian Meikle, editor

Australian Associated Press

Australian Associated Press

Share this

4 Responses to Trans woman’s case raises ‘constitutional matters’

Jackie says: 23 April 2023 at 7:52 pm

The real feminist movement has been hijacked by the trans movement and the pendulum has not swung too far. Pity for women everywhere. The West is destroying itself with lenient courts, leftist ideology and weak politicians.

Reply
David says: 28 April 2023 at 1:21 pm

The real femist movement should stand up to this crap. Biological males are still Biological males and no amount of hormone blockers and cosmetic surgery will change this.

Reply
Sarah says: 2 June 2023 at 2:12 am

One or more women are murdered by men every week in Australia. Every female survivor of family violence, including physical and sexual assault, is triggered by and becomes hypervigilant around the sight, presence, smell and voice of biological males. Sall Grover is trying to create a safe space for women where they can relax and don’t have to deal with their discomfort and fear around biological males. Lesbians by definition are not at all attracted to biological males. Why on earth would Tickle want to impose this level of distress on women who have joined Giggle?

Reply

Leave a Reply

Related Posts

Follow us on Instagram @canberracitynews