News location:

Wednesday, September 23, 2026 | Digital Edition | Crossword & Sudoku

What a shame the government’s killing dingoes

Dingoes… Namadgi National Park is home to one of the last genetically pure dingo populations in southeast Australia.

“Dingoes are not wild dogs. Using this vague term risks the needless killing of a native apex predator essential to healthy ecosystems,” says letter writer WHITNEY ANDERS RICHARDSON.

It is sad to hear that the ACT government’s Thermal Assisted Aerial Control (TAAC) program (until May 30) includes dingoes, mistakenly labelled as “wild dogs”. 

Write to [email protected]

While I support efforts to manage genuine invasive species like feral pigs and deer, the government needs to ensure dingoes are formally excluded from this operation.

Dingoes are not wild dogs. Research, including a major study from UNSW, shows most animals labelled as “wild dogs” are actually pure dingoes or dingo-dominant. Using this vague term risks the needless killing of a native apex predator essential to healthy ecosystems.

Namadgi National Park is home to one of the last genetically pure dingo populations in southeast Australia. 

A 2024 study confirmed this. These animals help control invasive species and are deeply significant to First Nations communities. What a shame to kill them instead of letting them thrive and support the ecosystems they have evolved in over thousands of years.

Whitney Anders Richardson, via email

Intrusion opens new unknown to energy supply

Engineers have said that the shutdown of the power grid across Spain, Portugal and parts of France on April 28-29 was caused either by a huge instability attributed to a lack of inertia in the system or by a lack of control over excess solar power in the system.

Whatever the investigations reveal, it will demonstrate how successful our governments, investors, climate catastrophists and media have been in creating the belief in the community that a renewable energy network is well understood and just needs time to be developed.

We only fully understand traditional high-voltage power grids in which synchronous high inertia supply follows demand. 

Systems in which electricity is generated by millions of low-voltage renewable modules and distributed bidirectionally pose many unresolved problems.

These systems have unprecedented quality problems to do with voltage and frequency caused by unreliability of supply as well as the unpredictability of both supply and demand.

While photovoltaics, wind turbines, batteries and inverters are everyday technology items, there is now the largely undeveloped requirement for real time informatics and control of the highly distributed renewable system. 

This is not discussed in the media and the community is not aware of the technology issues that may not be resolvable without some synchronous high-inertia generators in the system. This is where the case for nuclear power ultimately lies.

Furthermore, the intrusion of information, communications and control technologies into the energy system at every level will lead to new vulnerabilities.

Our most critical national infrastructure will be subject to cyber-attack, irrespective of almost every system component being designed and manufactured in China.

John L Smith, Farrer

Can we have a week off from politics?

Could we please have a week of no letters about politics from the perennial contributors? I am concerned that they rarely inspire constructive dialogue and I, for one, would appreciate a break after the comprehensive coverage/commentary leading up to the federal election.

Barry Peffer, Nicholls

Are we a nation of masochists?

After three years of this Albanese government, the MYEFO is predicting a $1 trillion national debt in 2025/2026 with no ideas about how to rein it in.

Many people are finding it hard to make ends meet with a very high cost of living, housing and renting, yet the government has been decisively returned for a second term, which begs the question: have we become a nation of masochists? Go figure .

Mario Stivala, Belconnen

The overwhelming number of votes do count

By now the parties and wakes will be over but while voting is still fresh in memory just to correct a couple of misapprehensions about voting mentioned in Letters (CN May 1).

John Godwin deplores preference deals and implies that somehow voters lose control of their preferences. This is not so. While parties/candidates may indicate how they suggest a voter allocates preferences on their how-to-vote cards, it is entirely up to each voter how they actually allocate their preferences. Voters don’t have to follow the suggestions.

John Murray’s suggestion that not voting counts more (than voting) is only partially correct in the Australian system. The US and UK have non-compulsory voting and first-past-the-post electoral systems. Australia, on the other hand, has compulsory voting (or at least attendance at a polling place) and preferential voting. 

Both ensure that an Australian’s vote counts for much more than in the US and UK.

Voter turnout in Australia is high, usually more than 90 per cent. Fewer than 5 per cent of votes cast in Australian elections cannot be counted. Only half of these are blank or despoiled ballots. This is only likely to make a difference to election outcomes in a very few, very marginal seats. So in Australia the overwhelming number of votes count.

Peter Tait, convenor, Canberra Alliance for Participatory Democracy

 

News all day, every day at CityNews.com.au.

Who can be trusted?

In a world of spin and confusion, there’s never been a more important time to support independent journalism in Canberra.

If you trust our work online and want to enforce the power of independent voices, I invite you to make a small contribution.

Every dollar of support is invested back into our journalism to help keep citynews.com.au strong and free.

Become a supporter

Thank you,

Ian Meikle, editor

Share this

2 Responses to What a shame the government’s killing dingoes

Jim says: 13 May 2025 at 8:51 am

Or perhaps Mario Stivala – Australians are clever enough to recognise a Government Budget is not a household budget…..

Reply
Ian MacDougall says: 25 June 2025 at 1:19 am

Your correspondent Whitney Anders Richardson says: “Namadgi National Park is home to one of the last genetically pure dingo populations in southeast Australia.
“A 2024 study confirmed this. These animals help control invasive species and are deeply significant to First Nations communities. What a shame to kill them instead of letting them thrive and support the ecosystems they have evolved in over thousands of years.”
According to the Wikipedia article on them (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dingo) “the earliest dingo skeletal remains in Australia are estimated at 3,450 YBP from the Mandura Caves on the Nullarbor Plain, south-eastern Western Australia…” But their presence post-1788 was not tolerated by sheep and cattle graziers. ‘Dingo’ became, understandably, a term of derision and abuse in our white settler communities; much the same as happened with regard to wild predators in Europe, Asia and the Americas. The result here in Australia has been loss of predators of the native macropod populations (ie, kangaroos and wallabies) providing a rationale for the ACT Government’s biennial slaughter. But there is a crucial difference: wild predators generally have a good eye for picking out the weaker, slower and ‘less fit,’ in their target species, and so minimise the danger to themselves in hunting them down.
A shooter with a modern rifle can take out the ‘biggest and the best’ of the target population, particularly if the hides are taken for their leather and/or fur, and the meat on-sold into the food trade, where it has a small gourmet market and a lively one for pet food. A shooter thus inevitably doubles as a gene selector, to the detriment of the whole macropod population. And the ACT politicians who give this the OK are (almost certainly unwittingly) heading the Eastern Grey Kangaroo to genetic decline ending in total extinction in the not-too-distant future, possibly helped along by a virus or two analagous to those causing AIDS in humans and myxomatosis in rabbits.
It gets worse: a declining macropod population to eat out the understorey vegetation on areas like Black Mountain and Farrer Ridge, will assist a repeat of the disastrous 2002-3 bushfire event. According to the National Museum website: “Four people died and 435 were injured as a result of the Canberra fires. Almost 70 per cent of the ACT was burned. A total of 487 homes and 23 government and commercial buildings were destroyed, including the internationally renowned Mount Stromlo Observatory. The estimated financial cost of the fires was between $600 million and $1 billion.
“The disaster prompted a series of major inquiries, including the ACT Government’s McLeod Inquiry and the ACT Coroner’s Inquiry. Both criticised the authorities for underestimating the scale of the firestorm and made recommendations to improve the territory’s future fire response.” (https://www.nma.gov.au/defining-moments/resources/canberra-bushfires)
My wife and I also came very close to losing our home, which is near Farrer Ridge.
Thanks to the brainless ‘conservation culls’ of kangaroos, this coming summer could see this disaster repeat. The fuel is there, and it’s set to go, and with precious few ‘roos to eat it down. Therefore, I suggest it be named the Barr-Rattenbury Disaster, in recognition of those politicians most responsible for it: When it inevitably comes.

Reply

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

*

*

Related Posts

Opinion

KEEPING UP THE ACT

First the iconic bus shelters are heritage listed, now our time-weathered chief has been heritage protected from removal, reports KEEPING UP THE ACT.

Opinion

Greens gambling tax call still doesn’t add up

"The Greens had an opportunity to demonstrate that their concern about the ACT's finances was serious enough to sit across the table from people they disagreed with and find common ground. And they chose not to," writes GWYN REES.

Follow us on Instagram @canberracitynews