News location:

Wednesday, October 7, 2026 | Digital Edition | Crossword & Sudoku

Defiant Hanson ‘sick of listening’ to migration experts

Pauline Hanson pipped the government with a plan to reduce the number of temporary visa holders. Lukas Coch/AAP PHOTOS

By Jacob Shteyman and Noah Secomb in Canberra

One Nation’s leader is adamant a policy to deliver “net-negative” migration won’t push Australia into recession.

Pauline Hanson dismissed concerns the party’s migration policy, which would lower immigration numbers by hundreds of thousands of people, had not been modelled for its economic impact.

Senator Hanson said she was “sick of listening” to bureaucrats, politicians and big business, adding they get it wrong on migration numbers and only care about cheap labour.

“We’re not addressing real concerns here,” she told News24 on Tuesday.

“Do you trust these economists, what they come out and say? Because I don’t.”

But Senator Hanson said she had no problem with the Parliamentary Budget Office looking at the policy, which would cut migration back to 2017 levels.

“Did the economy crash at that time? No,” she said.

One Nation MP Barnaby Joyce rubbished the Parliamentary Budget Office on Monday night, while defending the decision to release a migration policy without including the possible cost.

One Nation plans to reduce the number of temporary visa holders and overstayers by more than 750,000 over three years.

International student visas would bear the brunt of the cuts, with visa grants set to be reduced from more than 290,000 to 115,000 per year and secondary visas for family members eliminated.

Mr Joyce dismissed criticism for not modelling the economic impact of the policy or using the Parliamentary Budget Office to do so.

“They’re not elected. I am,” he told the ABC’s National Forum on Monday night, questioning the quality of the analysis provided by government agencies.

“I’ve never seen forward estimates in any budgetary paper being even close to the mark of what it’s supposed to do, and so the will of the Australian people is so pronounced. This has to be dealt with.”

Experts warned One Nation’s pledge to deliver three years of negative migration has only happened in times of severe economic stress and during World War II.

Industry Minister Tim Ayres said if the police was implemented, it would be a wrecking ball through regional economies.

“It would hurt the agriculture sector. It would hurt the hospitality and the aged care sectors in particular,” he said.

Labor’s decision to slow working visa applications has prompted criticism from the Australian Tourism Industry Council.

Chief executive Erin McLeod said the reduced intake of backpackers threatens the viability of many regional towns.

“Working holiday-makers fill critical roles where there are labour shortages across our regional destinations,” she said.

International pressures from higher fuel prices had already hit the regional tourism sector hard, due to lower visitor numbers during peak seasons, Ms McLeod said.

Nationals MP David Littleproud offered an “ironclad” pledge that the coalition’s policy will not include changes to any working holiday visa.

Intensifying debate over migration levels comes as the government is yet to announce how it will meet an annual net overseas migration forecast of 225,000 a year in the May budget.

The immigration minister was due to front the National Press Club earlier in August to outline changes to reduce migration levels, but he pulled out at the last minute over policy concerns that erupted during a Labor caucus meeting.

News all day, every day at CityNews.com.au.

Who can be trusted?

In a world of spin and confusion, there’s never been a more important time to support independent journalism in Canberra.

If you trust our work online and want to enforce the power of independent voices, I invite you to make a small contribution.

Every dollar of support is invested back into our journalism to help keep citynews.com.au strong and free.

Become a supporter

Thank you,

Ian Meikle, editor

Australian Associated Press

Australian Associated Press

Share this

4 Responses to Defiant Hanson ‘sick of listening’ to migration experts

David says: 16 September 2026 at 8:45 am

It’s not too surprising PH has taken this approach as those behind her will know it will resonate with the voters they are after. Whether PH realizes it or not she is pushing for a collapse in house prices and the so called experts aren’t doing a very good job of saying things that will resonate with potential ON voters. From what I saw from the Bare Investor on Super, he didn’t appear to address the issue of, when you retire and say you will have saved say $1M, would it be better as a home and no cash or cash and no home. At the end of every day everybody needs to find somewhere to sleep. In the current climate any discussion on super and retirement needs to have front and center where you will be sleeping and what that will look like physically and financially. Leave that out and no wonder PH can get away with saying, “why would I talk to so called experts”.

If the major parties want to tackle the challenges ON is posing then they need housing supply quickly and to be seen to be on the side of average Australians. Put a big public focus on ensuring every available property is being used (i.e. change the system to stop the rich owning vacant properties) plus drive property investors out of residential homes, i.e. bring down the number of people stuck in the rent cycle. Theis Robin Hood move that would help sway potential ON voters there is some hope the major parties will help them.

The government has made some bold steps to stop the financial rape of the housing market by property investors but failed to do one major thing. Clean up the mess that has already been caused which is being prevented by all the grandfathering mechanisms. The message is, we understand all you young average Australians have been locked out of the property market. However, while highlighting that we’ve decided to protect all the people that have caused the problem. A leaf out of the pages of religious institutions dealing with the behavioral problems of their members. This protectionism means any relief for the victims is still a long way away with the only distance that really matters being the next federal election. It is fueling ONs campaign. Battlers need to see changes now.

At this point in time, we need some level of immigration. We don’t need empty properties. We don’t need tax payer backed property investors collecting rent from people who should be buying.

Reply
cbrapsycho says: 16 September 2026 at 12:46 pm

I’m shocked that I’ve found something on which I can agree with Pauline Hanson. That is that all some businesses and politicians care about is cheap labour. This is not just big business.

As with the old 457 visas, businesses bring in people from countries where labour is cheap, knowing they’ll put up with workplace conditions and treatment that Australians will not tolerate. Those who’ve come in to work here need to send money home to their families, so they have little choice but to tolerate the abuse unless they have alternative work opportunities.

There are so many hospitality and construction industry workplaces dominated by temporary immigrants that existing Australian workers leave unwilling to be treated like slave labour, which is how many businesses treat those on visas and eventually Australian workers too. In some workplaces (especially kitchens) English or Australian language is not spoken by many workers, leaving them isolated and at increasing risk due to communication problems. As a result, our own people feel driven out of their jobs.

It is different in industries that are heavily regulated or unionised, where it is not so easy to do this. It mostly happens where it is not seen except by other workers. Particularly in trades, Australians walk away from their jobs and often their trade to get better work. This is part of the reason for poor retention in many trades.

Reply

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

*

*

Related Posts

News

Canberra Airport pitches new city stadium

Canberra Airport has proposed a new covered stadium near Commonwealth Park, arguing a city-centre venue could bring major sporting events, concerts and visitors into the heart of Canberra.

Follow us on Instagram @canberracitynews