News location:

Monday, October 12, 2026 | Digital Edition | Crossword & Sudoku

Why won’t Labor tell us what interest is costing?

Treasurer Chris Steel checks the tables, but no pie chart for John Miller. (Lukas Coch/AAP PHOTOS)

“I wrote to the ACT Revenue Office and to the ACT Treasurer. I even included a ‘revised’ pie chart. I received an obfuscating, non-answer. Three further times, I politely requested clarification. No acknowledgements. Let alone any response,” says letter writer JOHN MILLER.

The third largest expenditure of taxpayers’ money is the interest payments on ACT Government debt (let alone any repayment of those debts).

Write to [email protected]

Financing costs are currently the fastest-growing sector of ACT government spending. The Select Committee on Estimates highlighted that interest repayments consume 20 per cent of the ACT’s taxation revenue.

Our annual rates notices, “What your rates fund”, includes a pie chart of expenditures. There is no mention of these growing government (debt related) outlays.

I wrote to the ACT Revenue Office and to the ACT Treasurer. I even included a “revised” pie chart. I received an obfuscating, non-answer. Three further times, I politely requested clarification. No acknowledgements. Let alone any response.

Canberra rates notices (with their rate demands) keep coming. Ignoring (hiding?) this important expenditure of our money.

John Miller, Flynn

Debt trap: Steel’s compounding pain as interest takes its toll

Sounded like he meant it

I see the work-experience kid, aka Treasurer Steel, has kiboshed the long-promised Tuggeranong Ice Centre on the grounds that it wasn’t “value for money”.

Said with a straight face, it sounded as if he meant it. I wonder if he applied the same unforgiving test to the 13-year disaster, Rattenbury’s toy tram.

Bob Gardiner, Isabella Plains

KEEPING UP THE ACT

We want a pool not a pop-up cafe 

The news that the owner of Big Splash intends to resolve outstanding lease issues by providing an unlicensed restaurant is unconscionable – and even more so that the ACT Government appears to have accepted this farce. 

For years, Canberrans have watched as this developer plays both the government and the public, steadily eroding the original vision for the site.

There must be a way to insist that the site return to its intended purpose: an adventure-style aquatic facility. The addition of a restaurant – unlicensed, no less – is not a solution; it’s a distraction. No one values a casual dining spot nearly as much as they value a functional, family-friendly pool.

Let’s be clear: outdoor swimming pools have limited use in Canberra’s climate. Jamison Pool, like the Civic Pool, urgently needs a permanent cover so it can be enjoyed year-round. To settle for anything less is an abrogation of the government’s responsibility – one for which we, as citizens, rightly hold them accountable.

Canberrans deserve better. We deserve a pool, not a pop-up café.

Russ Morison, Theodore

Mental jibe deserved an apology

While I am embarrassed at admitting I watched the recent Logie Awards, some of it was quite entertaining. 

However, I found it disturbing to hear comedian Dave Hughes speak about his “mental” uncle. I am not always a bah-humbug kind of person, however, I found it to be a very offensive comment. 

Our society lives with, essentially, an epidemic of people experiencing mental health issues, and I am one of them, as was my daughter, Brontë, who lost her life through her ill mental health and substance misuse.

Would we call someone who suffers from epilepsy a “seizure freak”, or a diabetic a “sugar/lack of sugar freak”? I genuinely doubt it.

Comments made by the likes of Dave Hughes merely compound and amplify the stigmatisation of people experiencing mental health issues.

He should have apologised for his derogatory comments.

Janine Haskins, Cook

Tobacco fears for backward Canberra

The penalties for illicit trade in the ACT are way behind what has happened in NSW, Queensland and Victoria, which raise fears the territory will become a safe haven for organised crime and illegal tobacco. 

Canberra has no closure laws and a fine of only $1600 for its 693 licensed tobacconists. 

Queensland Health can issue an on-the-spot closure order shutting a store for up to 90 days without a court order. Courts can extend the closure for up to 12 months. Breaching a closure order carries a maximum penalty of $33,380. 

In a 10-day enforcement blitz (Operation Major, late 2025), 148 stores were issued three-month closure orders and product worth an estimated $15.7 million was seized.

In NSW, selling illicit tobacco or possessing a commercial quantity can result in up to seven years imprisonment, fines up to $1.54 million, or both.

During 2025, NSW Health inspectors seized over 16.2 million cigarettes, 2650kg of other illicit tobacco, and 215,000 illegal vaping goods, with prosecutions and fines totalling hundreds of thousands of dollars.

In Victoria, anyone found selling illicit tobacco faces fines of up to $370,000 or up to 15 years in jail, while businesses risk fines of more than $1.8 million.

The 2025-26 Victorian Budget included $46 million to establish the new licensing scheme and regulator to oversee the legal supply of tobacco products including licensing, compliance and enforcement. Reports indicate that almost every tobacco store across 110 suburbs was found to be selling illicit nicotine products.

Elizabeth Thurbon, Campbell

Political trust undermined by treats

Prevarication by our deputy prime minister knows no bounds. When defending the recent exposure of the federal transport minister’s acceptance of a lifetime of substantial Qantas platinum club membership benefits, he blithely stated: “This is what happens with airlines. They do this. I don’t think there’s much to see here”. 

Then, when asked whether he had lifetime platinum status himself, Richard Marles said he wasn’t sure. 

Either he was being quite disingenuous, or the comment shows that acceptance of such a highly valuable and exclusive gesture is easily lost sight of among the many offerings that can be snaffled up by ministers, so long as they make a declaration under rubbery requirements linked to the ministerial code of conduct and register of interests. 

It seems that keeping track of one’s “interests” and associated inter-relationships might turn out to be quite a burden for the minds, if not the consciences, of some of our key politicians. 

Given how this might interfere with the need to behave and avoid conflicts of interest in the workplace and public life in general, bestowal of corporate and lobby group largesse on our elected public representatives should not be allowed in any shape or form, including as promised deliverables after leaving politics. 

Sue Dyer, Downer

Stop footy reviews at higher resolution

There have been concerns about the video review system in rugby league.

A possible solution may be to stop reviews at higher-resolution images. Otherwise also, as technology improves, a game can literally be won or lost on a blade of grass!

Moreover, unless a player is injured, a referee or the bunker should no longer be permitted to review footage more than 60 seconds after the incident. Adopting these measures will reduce controversy and help improve the flow of the game.

Herman van de Brug, Holt

Better to restore endangered wildlife

As a Tasmanian, I fully appreciate the fascination with the thylacine, or Tasmanian tiger. 

Colossal Biosciences’ $10 million bid to “de-extinct” the species through genetic engineering is, however, a misplaced priority (“Science on verge of catching a tiger by the gene trail”, citynews.com.au, September 12).

We are living through a sixth mass extinction and more than 2000 Australian species are currently threatened.

Rather than trying to resurrect an animal lost nearly a century ago, our resources would be far better directed towards protecting and restoring the wildlife and ecosystems that still survive.

Conservation should focus on preventing extinctions, not trying to reverse them.

Sharee McCammon, Pelverata, Tasmania

 

News all day, every day at CityNews.com.au.

Who can be trusted?

In a world of spin and confusion, there’s never been a more important time to support independent journalism in Canberra.

If you trust our work online and want to enforce the power of independent voices, I invite you to make a small contribution.

Every dollar of support is invested back into our journalism to help keep citynews.com.au strong and free.

Become a supporter

Thank you,

Ian Meikle, editor

Share this

5 Responses to Why won’t Labor tell us what interest is costing?

Jim says: 22 September 2026 at 8:45 am

John Miller could just go and read the Budget papers, to see what he is seeking in terms of information.

But much easier to waste people’s time and then have a whine about it instead it seem.s

Reply
Mark R says: 22 September 2026 at 1:30 pm

If John Miller must read the Budget papers to get this information, then so must every other ratepayer. How many of them are going to be inclined to do that?

The point seems to be that the rates notices are an opportunity to use the attention that they draw to place an overview of the ACT Government’s financial activity before those ratepayers. If the current ACT Government is using this opportunity to present that information in a way that conceals or misleads, then surely that is worse for us than not presenting it at all. (Not to mention that ratepayer money is being used to draft up and print out those selective pie charts. Though, the cost of doing so would no doubt be but a vanishingly small sliver of the pie.)

With only John’s account of an ‘obfuscating, non-answer’ from the ACT Revenue Office and/or ACT Treasurer to go by at this point, it is difficult to judge if this response was indeed unsatisfactory by reasonable expectations. Understandably, the space afforded letter writers doesn’t allow for quoting details at length.

Reply
Curious Canberran says: 22 September 2026 at 3:52 pm

A fair point John.
I imagine interest costs are spread proportionally across each category of the “What your rates fund” pie.
I can’t imagine why you weren’t answered plainly after your multiple requests.
I think that’s deliberately hiding this cost item – so it doesn’t stand out.

And to challenge this intentional disguise, my last Federal Tax return included the single page ‘Tax Receipt’ (which after thanking you for paying your taxes), itemises the Australian Government debt levels. Alas, a mere bar chart and not as sensational as a pie .
And behold – there is a very clear independent line item: ‘Interest on Government Debt’.
ref: https://www.ato.gov.au/individuals-and-families/your-tax-return/your-notice-of-assessment/tax-receipt

Reply
Peter Bradbury says: 22 September 2026 at 6:24 pm

If you go to the Budget Papers you don’t get the answer, you get the following word salad:

“While data reported under both frameworks largely overlap, there are differences that
reflect the different purposes for which the data are collected. For example, the Where our
Money Goes data is sourced directly from agency budget statements by output class and do
not fully account for expenses such as those associated with whole of government public
debt management, as the purpose of the framework is to focus on delivery of government
services in the Territory. This data also includes expenses for ACT Housing and Transport
Canberra Operations which are partially excluded from the GFS general government
framework.” (Outlook document p 164)

Bottom line, interest on debt is completely or largely excluded from the “What your rates fund” graphic

Reply

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

*

*

Related Posts

Opinion

Justice delayed: how to speed up slow judges

"The selection of our judiciary is quaint. The community might reasonably expect that applicants demonstrate a capacity to write a decision prior to appointment. That doesn’t happen." HUGH SELBY has some ideas to speed up slow judgments.

Opinion

Heavy downsides to losing weight in space

"After weeks or months in orbit, astronauts experience dramatic but short-lived symptoms. Many describe an overwhelming heaviness, as if their arms and legs are made of lead." Whimsy columnist CLIVE WILLIAMS looks at weightlessness.

Follow us on Instagram @canberracitynews