News location:

Canberra Today 14°/17° | Wednesday, November 29, 2023 | Digital Edition | Crossword & Sudoku

Greens’ Laura Nuttall likely, but not a certainty

Laura Nuttall… most likely to replace Davis.

“Some will argue that a candidate with just 3 per cent of the primary vote ought not be able to be elected,” writes politica; columnist MICHAEL MOORE. 

 WHO is most likely to replace Johnathan Davis on his resignation from the ACT Legislative Assembly? 

Michael Moore.

The Greens will be hoping that the Hare-Clark method of filling a vacancy by countback will favour their party. Although this is likely, it is certainly not guaranteed.

Three years have passed since the last election and most of the unsuccessful candidates have got on with their own lives, set new goals and established themselves in other workplaces. 

The Electoral Commission will check with candidates to see if they are still willing to stand for election by countback before a decision can be made by November 27.

The countback process can then commence. The Electoral Commission will look at the votes that were cast in favour of Davis and then redistribute them according to the voters’ preferences. 

This will include the primary votes as well as those votes that Davis received after preferences flowed through to him. About a third of Davis votes were primary – the rest were preferences.

In the seat of Brindabella, which is largely based on Tuggeranong, the Greens won 10.8 per cent of the primary vote with 5.4 per cent going to Davis. He was well ahead of the other two Greens candidates, Laura Nuttall (3 per cent) and Sue Ellerman (2.4 per cent). Only in the electorate of Yerrabi (Gungahlin) did the Greens score a lower percentage of the votes. 

Labor’s Taimus Werner-Gibbings did not get elected despite having substantially higher first-preference votes than Davis at 8.2 per cent. Such is the power of preferences. It is an important lesson for both voters and candidates to remember just how critical preferences are in the ACT elections.

Using the Bouckaert ACT election countback simulator, it is Werner-Gibbings who is the first non-Greens candidate with a chance of being elected. However, the calculator finds that Nuttall (should she agree to stand for election) will replace Davis as an MLA. Should she decline the next in order is Ellerman followed by Werner-Gibbings.

Some will argue that a candidate with just 3 per cent of the primary vote ought not be able to be elected. However, keep in mind that there are five candidates to be elected from this electorate and therefore the percentage of votes to be elected in Brindabella (a quota) was close to 17 per cent. The reason it is less than 20 per cent is because not all votes are formal, and quite a few will be wasted.

Voters who give their first preference to the Greens tend to remain in the party grouping for other preferences. The Bouckaert calculator shows that the last candidates to remain in the count after distribution of preferences are in order: Nuttall and Ellerman (Greens Party), Werner-Gibbings (Labor Party) and Andrew Clapham (Sustainable Australia – Stop overdevelopment. Stop corruption Party).

Nuttall graduated from ANU with a double degree in politics, philosophy and economics/Asian studies. Her election pitch remains available on the Greens website. It provides an insight into what was driving her in 2020.

“I believe that everyone has a right to a dignified, secure, and meaningful life.” she says.

“Too often the old parties put the interests of corporations and their donors before the people they are supposed to represent. That’s why we’re one of the richest cities in the world and could house and support everyone, yet we have so many people living on the streets and struggling to meet their basic needs.

“We’ve seen what’s possible during a crisis, and we need to use this moment to build a better normal. That means making sure that everyone has a place to call home, food on their table, and feels welcome in our community. I’m committed to supporting the one thing all politicians and political parties should focus on: people”.

The ACT Hare-Clark system works efficiently and effectively in filling casual vacancies without the need for a by-election as happens elsewhere. The challenge for any replacement MLA will be to make such a mark that their chances of being re-elected next year are substantially improved.

Michael Moore is a former member of the ACT Legislative Assembly and an independent minister for health. He has been a political columnist with “CityNews” since 2006.

Who can be trusted?

In a world of spin and confusion, there’s never been a more important time to support independent journalism in Canberra.

If you trust our work online and want to enforce the power of independent voices, I invite you to make a small contribution.

Every dollar of support is invested back into our journalism to help keep citynews.com.au strong and free.

Become a supporter

Thank you,

Ian Meikle, editor

Michael Moore

Michael Moore

Share this

5 Responses to Greens’ Laura Nuttall likely, but not a certainty

cbrapsycho says: 20 November 2023 at 5:48 am

Laura Nuttall sounds like she has the character we need in the ACT Government to hold people to account. Let’s hope she moves into the role and serves us all well.

Reply
Palmerston's Lament says: 20 November 2023 at 6:59 am

Michael writes “The ACT Hare-Clark system works efficiently and effectively in filling casual vacancies without the need for a by-election as happens elsewhere.”

I would contend that this is the very opposite of what the democratic process is really about.

By-elections give the sitting Government a community health check, and reality check, on how they are governing. Their cost to the community is negligible but their impact goes far beyond their financial cost.

With 12 months to go, a by-election would show whether the Liberal push ahead of the 2024 election is having resonance with voters, how the public are ranking the effectiveness of the Greens and the Greens-Labor coalition, and give an opportunity for Teals to test the water.

Instead we will have an office staffer of a backbencher slouch into the slot.

Reply
Palmerston's Lament says: 21 November 2023 at 12:28 pm

The lack of any active press engagement by Nuttal in the lead up to the recount leaves me slightly concerned. There appears to be neither hunger nor zeal on display.

Reply

Leave a Reply

Related Posts

Political commentary

Back to the future in the Assembly

"The temptation for legislators is to seek convenient solutions. However, when a Commissioner for Human Rights can challenge legislators to rethink bills it ensures appropriate consideration," writes political columnist MICHAEL MOORE.

Follow us on Instagram @canberracitynews